A COMPARISON OF ANALYSIS METHODS FOR LATE‐STAGE VARIETY EVALUATION TRIALS

Authors:
  • BGBeverley J. Gogel
    Beverley J. Gogel
  • ASAlison B. Smith
    Alison B. Smith
  • RTRobin Thompson
    Robin Thompson
  • BCBrian R. Cullis
    Brian R. Cullis

Abstract
Summary: The statistical analysis of late‐stage variety evaluation trials using a mixed model is described, with one‐ or two‐stage approaches to the analysis. Two sets of trials, from Australia and the UK, were used to provide realistic scenarios for a simulation study to evaluate the different methods of analysis. This study showed that a one‐stage approach gave the most accurate predictions of variety performance overall or within each environment, across a range of models, as measured by mean squared error of prediction or realized genetic gain. A weighted two‐stage approach performed adequately for variety predictions both overall and within environments, but a two‐stage unweighted approach performed poorly in both cases. A generalized heritability measure was developed to compare methods.

This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit: