Source of bias in prenatal care utilization indices: implications for evaluating the Medicaid expansion.
Authors:
- M E TompkinsMTM E Tompkins
- D J PetersenDPD J Petersen
- J WeissJWJ Weiss
- 1 August 1991
- journal article
- Published by American Public Health Association in American Journal of Public Health
- Vol. 81 (8) , 1013-1016
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Recent expansions in eligibility for coverage of prenatal care services by the Medicaid program reflect national initiatives to improve pregnancy outcomes. This study investigates the potential impact that completeness of reporting of prenatal care and gestational age variables and strategies to impute missing data may have on evaluations of the Medicaid expansion. METHODS: This study, examining 15 years of vital record data from a single state and comparing 1 year of data from four mid-Atlantic states, selected single live births to resident mothers for analyses. The "day 15" and the "preceding case" methods were used to impute missing gestational age data. RESULTS: Considerable temporal and geographic variation was detected in completeness of reporting of variables used to construct prenatal care indices. After imputing values for cases with missing data, the proportion of cases for which adequacy of prenatal care utilization could not be determined ranged from 3% to 24% among the states investigated. For those cases where gestational age data could be imputed, the distribution of prenatal care utilization was not markedly disparate from those cases with complete reporting of gestational age. CONCLUSIONS: The results indicate that variations in reporting, decisions regarding the treatment of missing data, and the choice of the denominator can alter prenatal care utilization percentages and have implications for evaluations of the impact of the recent Medicaid expansion on prenatal care utilization.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Gestational age reporting and preterm delivery.1990
- The Differential Effect of Prenatal Care on the Incidence of Low Birth Weight among Blacks and Whites in a Prepaid Health Care PlanNew England Journal of Medicine, 1988
- Predictors of prenatal care utilizationSocial Science & Medicine, 1988
- Racial Disparities in Pregnancy Outcomes: The Role of Prenatal Care Utilization and Maternal Risk StatusAmerican Journal of Preventive Medicine, 1987
- PRENATAL-CARE UTILIZATION - ITS MEASUREMENT AND RELATIONSHIP TO PREGNANCY OUTCOME1987
- Factors associated with birthweight: an exploration of the roles of prenatal care and length of gestation.American Journal of Public Health, 1984
- Population-Based Intrauterine Growth Curves From Computerized Birth CertificatesSouthern Medical Journal, 1983
- FETAL GROWTH AND PERINATAL VIABILITY IN CALIFORNIA1982
- The effects of prenatal care upon the health of the newborn.American Journal of Public Health, 1979
- American Academy of Pediatrics. Committee on fetus and newborn. Nomenclature for duration of gestation, birth weight and intra-uterine growth.1967