Decisions and Structures: A Dialogue between Herbert Simon and Critical Realists
- 22 October 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in British Journal of Management
- Vol. 32 (4) , 1404-1420
Abstract
This paper compares critical realist (CR) approaches and their applications to management with Herbert Simon's account of individual and organizational cognition to provide an integrated framework for analysing the interaction between human beings and social structures. We establish several important conceptual and methodological affinities between both approaches, such as understanding decision and bounded rationality or emergentist accounts of organizations. Such affinities provide a coherent explanation of psychological mechanisms accounting for agency–structure interplay. With such an explanation, Simon's cognitivism leads to a deeper understanding of Margaret Archer's morphogenetic cycles and reflexivity, and affords fresh insight into David Elder‐Vass's mechanisms of organizational role‐playing. Simon's type of cognitivism is a social cognitivism as well, which addresses and incorporates other social sciences. It allows for a Simon‐CR analytical synthesis, which contributes to the individualism/structuralism debate in social and management research. We propose new arguments for separating structures from agency in organization studies. We elaborate key analytical implications of our synthesis, characterizing, in particular, deviant organizational culture and work division in both morphogenetic and Simonian terms.Keywords
This publication has 55 references indexed in Scilit:
- Where Constructionism and Critical Realism Converge: Interrogating the Domain of Epistemological RelativismOrganization Studies, 2011
- Testing management theories: critical realist philosophy and research methodsStrategic Management Journal, 2010
- Time, Self, and the Curiously Abstract Concept of Agency*Sociological Theory, 2007
- Critical Realism, Managers and InformationBritish Journal of Management, 1999
- Replication and Theory Development in Organizational Science: A Critical Realist PerspectiveAcademy of Management Review, 1999
- AbstractsJournal for the Theory of Social Behaviour, 1997
- The Soviet Transition from Socialism to Capitalism: Worker Control and Economic Bargaining in the Wood IndustryAmerican Sociological Review, 1992
- Sociology: Proscience or Antiscience?American Sociological Review, 1989
- Comments on the Theory of OrganizationsAmerican Political Science Review, 1952
- The Informal Organization of the Soviet FirmThe Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1952