Sceptical reflection about value tends to open up a disconcerting gulf between how ethical thought is, and how it seems to be. It is a good question exactly what it would take for ethical thought to be everything it seems. The answer will depend on how ethical thought in fact seems to some relevant ‘us’. It is often assumed that the nature of our ethical experience is determinate enough and fixed enough for there to be a number of general claims we can make about it once and for all. But the assumption is questionable. An important reason to question it is that our ethical experience may vary with the historical and cultural location of the ethical community-the ‘us’ to whom morality is seeming one way or another.