Holiday homes have become an increasingly important segment of the tourism offer in Croatia and may represent an attractive entrepreneurial investment. The aim of this paper is to assess the economic viability of a stylized investment in a holiday home in continental Croatia using cost-benefit analysis (CBA). The analysis considers an initial investment of €265,000, annual rental revenue of €36,000, annual operating costs of €5,500, a ten-year horizon, and a 6% discount rate. Two scenarios are distinguished. In the cash-flow scenario, which includes rental income only, the ten-year net present value (NPV) is –€40,517.34. In the extended CBA scenario, an imputed annual benefit of €6,000 from the owner’s personal use is added to rental income; this is a non-cash benefit and produces a ten-year NPV of €3,643.18. The results therefore show that the investment outcome is sensitive to the treatment of the owner’s personal-use benefit. Under the assumptions applied in this study, economic viability is achieved within ten years only when this imputed benefit is included. Social and environmental sustainability are discussed as broader contextual dimensions but are not directly evaluated in the empirical analysis.