Controls Who Experienced Hypothetical Causal Intermediates Should Not Be Excluded from Case-Control Studies
Author:
Open Access
- 15 September 1999
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in American Journal of Epidemiology
- Vol. 150 (6) , 547-551
Abstract
It has been suggested that controls with adenomatous polyps of the colon and rectum should be excluded from case-control studies of cigarette smoking and colorectal cancer. A claim has been made that the presence of such controls creates a bias toward the null. The polyps are an intermediate step in a hypothetical causal pathway between the exposure and the disease. Thus, the recommendation logically extends to the exclusion of all controls who experienced hypothetical causal intermediates from all case-control studies. It is shown, in the simple case of an exposure that acts solely through the pathway involving the intermediate, that such exclusions create a bias away from the null. The rationale for recommending the detrimental exclusions appears to stem from a variant of the “trohoc fallacy”: the mistaken view of case-control studies as comparisons between diseased and healthy groups and not as comparisons between groups that differ by exposure. Am J Epidemiol 1999; 150: 547-51.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cigarette Smoking and the Colorectal Adenoma-Carcinoma Sequence: A Hypothesis to Explain the ParadoxAmerican Journal of Epidemiology, 1998
- Invited Commentary: Old Problem, New WrinklesAmerican Journal of Epidemiology, 1998
- A Prospective Study of Cigarette Smoking and Risk of Colorectal Adenoma and Colorectal Cancer in U.S. WomenJNCI: Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 1994
- A Prospective Study of Cigarette Smoking and Risk of Colorectal Adenoma and Colorectal Cancer in U.S. MenJNCI: Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 1994
- Identifiability and Exchangeability for Direct and Indirect EffectsEpidemiology, 1992
- Theoretical Epidemiology: Principles of Occurrence Research in Medicine.1987
- EXPOSURE OPPORTUNITY IN CASE-CONTROL STUDIESAmerican Journal of Epidemiology, 1986
- The “case-control” study: Valid selection of subjectsJournal of Chronic Diseases, 1985
- SEQUENTIAL PATHOGENIC COMPONENTS OF RATESAmerican Journal of Epidemiology, 1979
- A Method of Estimating Comparative Rates from Clinical Data. Applications to Cancer of the Lung, Breast, and CervixJNCI: Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 1951