Diagnosing Insensitivity to Scope in Contingent Valuation
Authors:
Open Access
- 9 August 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Environmental and Resource Economics
- Vol. 77 (1) , 191-216
Abstract
Sensitivity to scope is considered a desirable property of contingent valuation studies and often treated as a necessary condition for validity. We first provide an overview of scope insensitivity explanations put forth in the environmental valuation literature. Then we analyze data from a contingent valuation survey eliciting willingness-to-pay to prevent oil spills of four different magnitudes in Arctic Norway. In the baseline analysis, the scope inference is ambiguous. There is only statistical difference in willingness to pay to avoid a very large versus small oil spill (NOK 1869 and NOK 1086, respectively). However, further explorations show that several confounding factors suggested in the literature influence the scope inference. The scope sensitivity improves when we control for subjective probabilities of amenity provision, exclude respondents based on the debriefing questions, take into consideration the sample sizes, and impose diminishing marginal utility. Overall, the analysis supports an emerging view in the contingent valuation literature suggesting that statistical scope insensitivity is not a sufficient reason for deeming a study invalid.Keywords
Funding Information
- Norges Forskningsråd (255777)
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- Identifying the scope effect on a meta-analysis of biodiversity valuation studiesResource and Energy Economics, 2011
- Economic Valuation of Environmental Damages due to the Prestige Oil Spill in SpainEnvironmental and Resource Economics, 2009
- Using Labels to Investigate Scope Effects in Stated Preference MethodsEnvironmental and Resource Economics, 2009
- Incentive and informational properties of preference questionsEnvironmental and Resource Economics, 2007
- An Accidental Oil Spill Along the Belgian Coast: Results from a CV StudySSRN Electronic Journal, 2006
- The Willingness to Pay for Property Rights for the Giant Panda: Can a Charismatic Species Be an Instrument for Nature Conservation?Land Economics, 2003
- Scope (in)sensitivity in elicited valuationsRisk Decision and Policy, 1998
- Part-Whole Bias in Contingent Valuation: Will Scope Effects Be Detected with Inexpensive Survey Methods?Southern Economic Journal, 1998
- Testing Willingness-to-Pay Models of Discrete Choice Contingent Valuation Survey DataLand Economics, 1995
- Contingent Valuation: Is Some Number Better than No Number?Journal of Economic Perspectives, 1994