Comparing Different Phosphorus Extraction Methods: Effects of Influencing Parameters
Authors:
Open Access
- 14 February 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 14 (4) , 2158
Abstract
The current study compares the phosphorus (P) analysis methods of ammonium lactate (AL), Mehlich 3 (M3); water extraction (P-WA(P)&P-WA(PO4)), cobalt hexamine (CoHex) and X-ray fluorescence (XRF) as an estimate of total soil P. The ratio of the P-content/XRF was first calculated and compared with the whole dataset. Based on the comparison of all the data, there were significant differences between the results of P-WA(P) and P-WA(PO4) vs. M3 and AL, CoHex vs. M3 and CoHex vs. AL methods (p < 0.001). The second step was the analysis of the influencing factors based on their categories for a more in-depth understanding of their role (CaCO3-content, pH, soil texture and clay content). The results showed that higher CaCO3 content (>1%) resulted in lower correlations (6/10 cases). The extraction methods, the soil, the classification method of the soil properties and the statistical analyses affect the evaluation. The dataset covers a good range of the analysed factors for the evaluation of phosphorus in the majority of Hungarian soil types in arable use. There were two methods that detected the largest amount of P from the total P in the soil: AL and M3.Keywords
Funding Information
- Széchenyi István Egyetem (TKP2020-NKA-14)
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Conceptual design and quantification of phosphorus flows and balances at the country scale: The case of FranceGlobal Biogeochemical Cycles, 2012
- Relationships between the Mehlich‐III soil test extraction procedure and standard soil test methods in North DakotaCommunications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 1998
- Soil phosphorus: its measurement, and its uptake by plantsSoil Research, 1997
- Comparison of extractants for the determination of available phosphorus, potassium, calcium, magnesium and sodium in some Ethiopian and German soilsCommunications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 1996
- Comparison of mehlich 1‐, 2‐, and 3‐, calcium chloride‐, bray‐, olsen‐, enger‐, and schachtschabel‐extractants for determinations of nutrient in two soil typesCommunications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 1994
- New diagnostic techniques, universal soil extractantsCommunications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 1994
- Comparison of mehlich 3, mehlich 1, ammonium bicarbonate‐DTPA, 1.0M ammonium acetate, and 0.2M ammonium chloride for extraction of calcium, magnesium, phosphorus, and potassium for a wide range of soilsCommunications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 1993
- Soil testing and plant analysis in Western EuropeCommunications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 1992
- Evaluation of Mehlich‐III extractant to estimate the available P in Quebec soilsCommunications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 1990
- An effective water extraction method for the determination of plant-available soil phosphorusPlant and Soil, 1971