Using synthetic RNA to benchmark poly(A) length inference from direct RNA sequencing
Open Access
- 6 January 2025
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in GigaScience
- Vol. 14
Abstract
Polyadenylation is a dynamic process that is important in cellular physiology, which has implications in messenger RNA decay rates, translation efficiency, and isoform-specific regulation. Oxford Nanopore Technologies direct RNA sequencing provides a strategy for sequencing the full-length RNA molecule and analysis of the transcriptome. Several tools are currently available for poly(A) tail length estimation, including well-established methods like tailfindr and nanopolish, as well as more recent deep learning models like Dorado. However, there has been limited benchmarking of the accuracy of these tools against gold-standard datasets. In this article, we present our novel deep learning poly(A) estimation tool—BoostNano—and compare with 3 existing tools—tailfindr, nanopolish, and Dorado. We evaluate the 4 poly(A) estimation tools, using 2 sets of synthetic in vitro transcribed RNA standards with known poly(A) tail lengths—Sequin (30 or 60 nucleotides) and enhanced green fluorescent protein (10–150 nucleotides) RNA. Analyzing datasets with known ground-truth values is a valuable approach to measuring the accuracy of poly(A) length estimation. The tools demonstrated length- and sample-dependent performance, and accuracy was enhanced by averaging over multiple reads via estimation of the peak of the density distribution. Overall, Dorado is recommended as the preferred approach due to its relatively fast runtimes, low mean error, and ease of use with integration with base-calling. These results provide a reference for poly(A) tail length estimation analysis, aiding in improving our understanding of the transcriptome and the relationship between poly(A) tail length and other transcriptional mechanisms, including transcript stability or quantification.Keywords
All Related Versions
Funding Information
- NHMRC (GNT1195743)
This publication has 55 references indexed in Scilit:
- Two mutations in the beta-globin polyadenylylation signal reveal extended transcripts and new RNA polyadenylylation sites.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 1992
- Cleavage and polyadenylation factor CPF specifically interacts with the pre‐mRNA 3′ processing signal AAUAAA.The EMBO Journal, 1991
- The cap and poly(A) tail function synergistically to regulate mRNA translational efficiency.Genes & Development, 1991
- A novel poly(A)-binding protein acts as a specificity factor in the second phase of messenger RNA polyadenylationCell, 1991
- Site-directed ribose methylation identifies 2′-OH groups in polyadenylation substrates critical for AAUAAA recognition and poly(A) additionCell, 1991
- A multicomponent complex is required for the AAUAAA-dependent cross-linking of a 64-kilodalton protein to polyadenylation substrates.Molecular and Cellular Biology, 1990
- Four factors are required for 3'-end cleavage of pre-mRNAs.Genes & Development, 1989
- Role of poly(A) polymerase in the cleavage and polyadenylation of mRNA precursor.Molecular and Cellular Biology, 1989
- The 3$prime; terminal sequences of human $alpha; and $beta; globin messenger RNAs: Comparison with rabbit globin messenger RNACell, 1976
- 3′ Non-coding region sequences in eukaryotic messenger RNANature, 1976