Abstract
Family-based tilapia farming has expanded in Brazil, yet evidence comparing the environmental performance of different production systems remains limited. We therefore conducted a cradle-to-gate life cycle assessment as a comparative case study of four family-based Oreochromis niloticus farming systems in the Itamarati Rural Settlement (Mato Grosso do Sul, Brazil): earthen pond, lined pond, net cage, and elevated tank. The study adopted a cradle-to-gate scope and a functional unit of 1 t of harvested live fish. The life cycle inventory combined primary and secondary data, while biosphere emissions were estimated using a Brazilian aquaculture-oriented model (Agri-Peixe). Impact assessment was performed in SimaPro (PhD 9.2.0.2), using the ReCiPe method (Midpoint H) and Ecoinvent (v.3.9.1) and Agri-footprint (v.6.3) databases. Results differed across systems, ranging from 2216.5–3229.5 kg CO2-eq (climate change), 9.2–17.1 kg SO2-eq (terrestrial acidification), 1.2–1.7 kg P-eq (freshwater eutrophication), 31.9–33.5 kg N-eq (marine eutrophication), 2142.4–2563.2 m2·a (agricultural land occupation), and 12.1–11148.8 m3 (water consumption). Earthen ponds showed higher values for climate change and water consumption, whereas net cages showed lower values in most categories; overall results indicate system-specific trade-offs. Contribution analysis identified feed as the dominant hotspot (notably the 32% crude-protein diet), followed by infrastructure in earthen ponds and electricity in tank-based systems. Excluding infrastructure in a scenario analysis substantially changed results for earthen ponds, highlighting sensitivity to infrastructure modeling assumptions. Mitigation should focus on feed efficiency and formulation, energy optimization, and water-loss reduction, tailored to each production system.

This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit: