Exemplary and Surrogate Models: Two Modes of Representation in Biology
- 1 September 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Project MUSE in Perspectives in Biology and Medicine
- Vol. 52 (4) , 485-499
Abstract
Biologists use models in two distinct ways that have not been clearly articulated. A model may be used either as an exemplar of a larger group, or as a surrogate for a specific target. Zebrafish serve as an exemplary model of vertebrates in developmental biology; rodents are both exemplary vertebrates and specific surrogates for humans in biomedical research. The distinction between exemplary and surrogate models is important, because the criteria for and implications of model choice diverge in significant ways, depending on which role the model is to serve. So, too, do the kinds of conclusions we can legitimately draw from model-based research. The divergence derives in part from the use of the two sorts of models to answer different kinds of questions: exemplary models most often serve basic research, while surrogate models are used when the target species we ultimately want to learn about is inaccessible or difficult to study, as in medical research. There are many reasons to consider exemplary and surrogate models separately: they are suited to different tasks and contexts, rest on different assumptions, and, finally, they have unique limitations.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Reprogramming of Human Somatic Cells Using Human and Animal OocytesCloning and Stem Cells, 2009
- Neural tube defects and folate: case far from closedNature Reviews Neuroscience, 2006
- Behavioral analysis of stress controllability effects in a new swim stress paradigmPharmacology Biochemistry and Behavior, 2001
- Fashioning Descriptive Models in Biology: Of Worms and Wiring DiagramsPhilosophy of Science, 2000
- Model systems in developmental biologyBioEssays, 1995
- A Phylogenetic Perspective on Teleost GastrulationThe American Naturalist, 1994
- The Right Tools for the Job: At Work in Twentieth-Century Life SciencesTechnology and Culture, 1993
- Gastrulation and mesoderm morphogenesis in the white sturgeonJournal of Experimental Zoology, 1993
- How the choice of experimental organism matters: Epistemological reflections on an aspect of biological practiceJournal of the History of Biology, 1993
- The Wistar rat as a right choice: Establishing mammalian standards and the ideal of a standardized mammalJournal of the History of Biology, 1993