Retention Bans Are Beneficial but Insufficient to Stop Shark Overfishing
Open Access
- 3 March 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Fish and Fisheries
- Vol. 26 (3) , 473-487
Abstract
Sharks are among the most threatened groups of exploited fishes, comprising common bycatch across many fisheries. Management efforts intended to safeguard threatened species have increasingly focused on retention bans to reduce bycatch mortality. However, the population effects of such measures remain unevaluated across species. We combined available data from 160 studies providing estimates of at‐vessel or post‐release mortality for 147 taxa caught by different fishing gears to create random‐forest regression models and predict mortality rates for 341 shark species incidentally captured by longlines or gillnets. Smaller‐bodied species inhabiting shallow waters were more likely to suffer at‐vessel mortality compared to their deep‐water counterparts, for which post‐release mortality was more likely to occur. We then used results for longlines to simulate the effect of retention bans in reducing fishing mortality to sustainable levels. Our metric consists of the ratio between the proportion of each species' population caught and discarded (PMAX) under a retention ban divided by the fishing mortality (F) predicted to achieve maximum sustainable yield (FMSY). Our calculations show that a retention ban yielded an average ~ three‐fold higher PMAX compared to FMSY, with 18% of the species having PMAX/FMSY < 2, 72.3% having 2 < PMAX/FMSY < 5, and 9.7% having PMAX/FMSY > 5. For threatened species, median PMAX/FMSY = 2.28 and non‐threatened ones had median PMAX/FMSY = 2.77. Our study shows that retention bans could reduce shark mortality, but must be combined with additional measures to stop overfishing, especially for low‐productivity species.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship Program (2139319)
- Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior (001)
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- Tropical rays are intrinsically more sensitive to overfishing than the temperate skatesBiological Conservation, 2023
- Body mass, temperature, and depth shape the maximum intrinsic rate of population increase in sharks and raysEcology and Evolution, 2022
- Reproductive Biology of the Pacific Spadenose Shark Scoliodon Macrorhynchos, a Heavily Exploited Species in the Southern Taiwan StraitMarine and Coastal Fisheries, 2022
- A closer look at the bycatch of medium‐sized and large sharks in the northern Catalan coast (north‐western Mediterranean Sea): Evidence of an ongoing decline?Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems, 2021
- Less Soak Time Saves Those upon the Line: Capture Times and Hooking Mortality of Sharks Caught on Bottom LonglinesNorth American Journal of Fisheries Management, 2021
- The consumption of shark meat in the Amazon region and its implications for human health and the marine ecosystemChemosphere, 2021
- Potential distribution and population trends of the smalltail shark Carcharhinus porosus inferred from species distribution models and historical catch dataAquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems, 2020
- Standardized catch and survival rates, and effect of a ban on shark retention, Palau pelagic longline fisheryAquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems, 2015
- Recovery potential of smalltooth sawfish, Pristis pectinata, in the United States determined using population viability modelsAquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems, 2014
- Forecasting elasmobranch survival following exposure to severe stressorsComparative Biochemistry and Physiology Part A: Molecular & Integrative Physiology, 2012