Challenging East–West value dichotomies and essentialising discourse on culture and social work
- 18 September 2007
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in International Journal of Social Welfare
- Vol. 16 (4) , 398-407
Abstract
All discourse, whether universalistic and/or particularistic, must be subject to contestation, so that we are held accountable for the thinking that we articulate in our writings, and so that we do not reinforce much of the taken for granted assumptions about the world. Critiques such as those of Hutchings and Taylor in this issue of IJSW remind us of social work's commitment to reflexivity and the need to contest discourse that might not be in the interests of particular groups of people. It is not the debate itself contained in the article that is an issue, but the framing of the debate and the assumptions upon which they are predicated. The discourse on human rights within the liberal democratic framework, in a rapidly globalising world characterised by neoliberal capitalism, needs to be critiqued on a global level. Hutchings and Taylor's article assumes the applicability and suitability of liberal democracy for the West and not for the East, with an assumption that the West is characterised by liberalism and the East by tradition and a bureaucratic authoritarianism. It is these assumptions, and the tendency to essentialise Chinese and Western culture and to reinforce the dichotomy between the West and the East, that I contest in this article.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Defining the profession? Exploring an international definition of social work in the China contextInternational Journal of Social Welfare, 2007
- Chinese culture, social work education and researchInternational Social Work, 2005
- Social work in ChinaInternational Social Work, 2005
- Global standards for the education and training of the social work profession*International Journal of Social Welfare, 2005
- Defining Social Work for the 21st CenturyInternational Social Work, 2004
- Humanitarian Attitudes and Support of Government Responsibility for Social WelfareInternational Social Work, 2003
- Social Work and Ethnic Minorities' Social Development in the People's Republic of ChinaInternational Social Work, 2003
- Contingent on Context? Social Work and the State in Australia, Britain, and the USAThe British Journal of Social Work, 2003
- Tensions confronting the development of social work education in ChinaInternational Social Work, 2002
- Confucian welfare philosophy and social change technology: an integrated approach for international social developmentInternational Social Work, 1993