Does the Choice of Acellular Scaffold and Augmentation With Bone Marrow Aspirate Concentrate Affect Short-term Outcomes in Cartilage Repair? A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis
Authors:
- 28 February 2022
- journal article
- review article
- Published by SAGE Publications in The American Journal of Sports Medicine
- Vol. 51 (6) , 1622-1633
Abstract
Background: Matrix-induced chondrogenesis (MIC) is a promising treatment option for critical-size cartilage lesions of the knee; however, there exists substantial heterogeneity in the choice of acellular scaffold matrix for MIC cartilage repairs. Hypothesis: The choice of acellular matrix will not affect patient outcomes after MIC cartilage repair procedures, and the addition of concentrated bone marrow aspirate (cBMA) will improve short-term patient outcomes regardless of matrix choice. Study Design: Meta-analysis; Level of evidence, 4. Methods: Studies were stratified by matrix type: multilayered, single layered, and gel based. Continuous outcomes were analyzed with pairwise meta-analysis using the inverse variance model with random effects applied. Binary outcomes were analyzed as pooled proportions in a single-arm fashion; after which, reconstruction of relative risks (RRs) with confidence intervals was performed using the Katz logarithmic method. Results: A total of 876 patients were included: 469 received multilayered bioscaffolds; 238, gel-based scaffolds; and 169, single-layered scaffolds. The mean age of patients was 36.2 years (95% CI, 33.9 to 38.4), while the mean lesion size was 3.91 cm 2 (95% CI, 3.40 to 4.42). The weighted mean follow-up was 23.8 months (95% CI, 20.1 to 27.6). Multilayered bioscaffolds were most effective at improving visual analog scale scores ( P = .03; weighted mean difference [WMD], −4.44 [95% CI, −4.83 to −4.06]; P < .001). There were significantly lower risks of incomplete defect filling for gel-based scaffolds when compared with multilayered scaffolds (RR, 0.78 [95% CI, 0.69 to 0.88]; P < .001) and single-layered scaffolds (RR, 0.58 [95% CI, 0.41 to 0.81]; P = .001). Augmentation with cBMA further improved clinical scores across all scaffolds, with significant improvements in Tegner score ( P = .02), while decreasing incomplete defect filling rates as well. There was significantly greater improvement in visual analog scale scores ( P = .01) for single-layered scaffolds with cBMA augmentation (WMD, −4.88 [95% CI, −5.38 to −4.37]; P < .001) as compared with single-layered scaffolds without cBMA augmentation (WMD, −4.08 [95% CI, −4.46 to −3.71]; P < .001). All significant improvements were below their respective minimum clinically important differences. Conclusion: While cartilage repair with acellular scaffolds provides significant improvements in pain and function for patients, there is insufficient clinical evidence to suggest which scaffold material is the most superior in influencing such improvements. The enhancement of cartilage repair procedures with cBMA may provide further functional improvements and improve defect filling; however, more long-term evidence is required to evaluate the effects.Keywords
This publication has 48 references indexed in Scilit:
- Outcome of Autologous Matrix Induced Chondrogenesis (AMIC) in cartilage knee surgery: data of the AMIC RegistryArchives of orthopaedic and trauma surgery, 2012
- Assessing risk of bias in prevalence studies: modification of an existing tool and evidence of interrater agreementJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2012
- Supporting Biomaterials for Articular Cartilage RepairCARTILAGE, 2012
- Paper # 169: One‐Step Cartilage Transplantation for Full‐Thickness Lesions TreatmentArthroscopy, 2011
- All‐arthroscopic AMIC procedure for repair of cartilage defects of the kneeKnee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy, 2011
- Cartilage Injuries in the Adult KneeCARTILAGE, 2010
- 179 AUTOLOGOUS MATRIX INDUCED CHONDROGENESIS (AMIC PLUS) FOR THE TREATMENT OF PATELLAR CARTILAGE DEFECTS IN THE KNEEOsteoarthritis and Cartilage, 2010
- Treatment of articular cartilage lesions of the knee joint using a modified AMIC techniqueKnee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy, 2009
- Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials: Is blinding necessary?Controlled Clinical Trials, 1996
- Obtaining Confidence Intervals for the Risk Ratio in Cohort Studies1978