Rethinking reflexivity, replicability and rigour in qualitative research
Authors:
- 28 August 2025
- journal article
- Published by BMJ in Medical Humanities
- Vol. 52 (1) , 17-19
Abstract
This commentary re-examines recent proposals to define quality in qualitative research through a singular unifying framework, situating them alongside historical and ongoing debates in qualitative methodology. By juxtaposing different traditions, this piece highlights areas of tension between procedural notions of rigour and interpretive approaches that emphasise the co-constructed, context-bound nature of meaning. The discussion argues that quality in qualitative research cannot be captured by a single metric or universal rule. Reflexive approaches resist rigid frameworks, instead favouring a situational and evolving engagement with meaning. While efforts to promote transparency and accountability in qualitative research are valuable, researchers should adopt methodological criteria aligned with their epistemological commitments. We argue that qualitative research can be considered rigorous insofar as it is deeply reflective, explicitly contextualised and transparent about its interpretive manoeuvres.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- Lived experiences of patients, families and caregivers affected by inherited retinal diseases: A qualitative systematic reviewDisability and Health Journal, 2025
- “This is life”: An interpretative phenomenological analysis of the lived experience of working-age adults with inherited retinal diseases in SingaporeDisability and Health Journal, 2025
- The quality of qualitative researchMedical Humanities, 2024
- A critical review of the reporting of reflexive thematic analysis in Health Promotion InternationalHealth Promotion International, 2024
- To saturate or not to saturate? Questioning data saturation as a useful concept for thematic analysis and sample-size rationalesQualitative Research in Sport, Exercise and Health, 2019
- But Is It Phenomenology?Qualitative Health Research, 2017
- Body and self: a phenomenological study on the ageing body and identityMedical Humanities, 2006
- Qualitative Research: Rigour and qualitative researchBMJ, 1995