Suspicious activity reporting in the United Kingdom and the United States: statutory obligations of auditors and optimal harvesting of information
Author:
- 6 November 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Money Laundering Control
- Vol. 27 (3) , 432-444
Abstract
Purpose: This study aims to evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of auditor mandatory suspicious activity reporting versus the exercise of professional judgement in the anti-money laundering regimes of the UK and the USA. Design/methodology/approach: The research draws upon the following sources. Firstly, statistics provided by the UK National Crime Agency, 2019 (NCA) regarding suspicious activity report (SAR) filing rates. Secondly, anti-money laundering legislation in the USA and UK. Thirdly, statements made in the political domain in the USA, particularly those which raised constitutional concerns during the progress of the Patriot Act 2001. Finally, statements and recommendations by a UK Parliamentary Commission enquiring into the effectiveness of the suspicious activity reporting regime. Findings: The UK reporting regime does not accommodate professional judgement, resulting in the filing of SARs with limited intelligence value. This contrasts with discretionary reporting in the USA: voluntary reporting guides and influences auditor behaviour rather than mandating it. Defensive filing by UK auditors (defence to anti-money launderings [DAMLs]) has increased in recent years but the number of SARs filed has declined. Originality/value: The study evaluates auditor behavioural responses to legislative regimes which mandate or alternatively accommodate discretion in the reporting suspicion of money laundering. Consideration of constitutional and judicial activism in this context is a novel contribution to the literature. For its theoretical framework the study uses Foucault’s concept of discipline of the self to evaluate auditor behaviour under both regimes.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Perceived importance of red flags across fraud typesCritical Perspectives on Accounting, 2013
- Auditors’ Organizational Form, Legal Liability, and Reporting Conservatism: Evidence from China*Contemporary Accounting Research, 2011
- A Theory of "Crying Wolf" : The Economics of Money Laundering EnforcementThe Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization, 2009
- Money laundering, Terrorism, Regulation, Laws and legislationJournal of Money Laundering Control, 2003
- The Sovereign State v Foucault: Law and Disciplinary PowerThe Sociological Review, 2000
- “Presents” for the “Indians”: land, colonialism and accounting in CanadaAccounting, Organizations and Society, 2000
- Sweeping it under the carpet: The role of accountancy firms in moneylaunderingAccounting, Organizations and Society, 1998
- Forensic accounting education: insights from academicians and certified fraud examiner practitionersManagerial Auditing Journal, 1997
- Dynamics of Interorganizational Attachments: Auditor-Client RelationshipsAdministrative Science Quarterly, 1988
- Accounting systems and systems of accountability — understanding accounting practices in their organisational contextsAccounting, Organizations and Society, 1985