Motor Learning Mechanisms are not modified by Feedback Manipulations in a Real-World Task
Preprint
Abstract
Error-based and reward-based mechanisms of motor learning co-occur in real-world scenarios but are traditionally isolated in laboratory tasks via feedback manipulations. This study examines the distinctiveness of these mechanisms by applying a lab-based feedback manipulation to a real-world task. Using Embodied Virtual Reality (EVR) of pool billiards - allowing for full proprioception via interaction with the physical pool table, cue stick, and balls - we introduced visual perturbations to a real-world task. 32 participants (12 F) underwent two sessions learning a visuomotor rotation, once with error and once with reward feedback. While naive participants corrected the entire rotation with error feedback, only partial correction was observed with reward feedback, highlighting the influence of the feedback regime on learning. However, the reward-dependent motor variability, lag-1 autocorrelation decay, and inter-trial variability decay - all indicators of reward-based and skill learning - were higher in the error feedback session, suggesting that the provided visual feedback did not exclusively engage specific learning mechanisms. Analysis of post-movement beta rebound (PMBR), a brain activity marker of learning mechanisms, revealed a decrease in PMBR with reward feedback but no consistent trend during error feedback sessions. These findings support the behavioural results, suggesting that while reward feedback was absent in error conditions, participants still engaged in reward-based learning. This study underscores the complexity of motor learning processes and highlights that visual feedback by itself can not elucidate the interplay between error-based and reward-based mechanisms in real-world contexts.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: npj Science of Learning, 10 (1), 1.
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- Implicit reward-based motor learningExperimental Brain Research, 2023
- It's not (only) the mean that matters: variability, noise and exploration in skill learningCurrent Opinion in Behavioral Sciences, 2018
- Girls can play ball: Stereotype threat reduces variability in a motor skillActa Psychologica, 2016
- Cerebellar and Prefrontal Cortex Contributions to Adaptation, Strategies, and Reinforcement Learning2014
- Reinforcement learning in the brainJournal of Mathematical Psychology, 2009
- Variability in motor learning: relocating, channeling and reducing noiseExperimental Brain Research, 2008
- Short-term learning of a visually guided power-grip task is associated with dynamic changes in EEG oscillatory activityClinical Neurophysiology, 2008
- Reorganization and plasticity in the adult brain during learning of motor skillsCurrent Opinion in Neurobiology, 2005
- EEGLAB: an open source toolbox for analysis of single-trial EEG dynamics including independent component analysisJournal of Neuroscience Methods, 2004
- A computational model of four regions of the cerebellum based on feedback-error learningBiological Cybernetics, 1992