Dilemmas in fetal medicine: premature application of technology or responding to women's choice?
- 1 January 2006
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Sociology of Health & Illness
- Vol. 28 (1) , 1-20
Abstract
It is argued that innovative health technologies (IHTs) may be changing the roles of both patients and health practitioners, and raising new issues, including ethical, legal and social dilemmas. This paper focuses on the innovative area of fetal medicine. All fetal treatment necessitates accessing the fetus through the pregnant woman's body, and non‐surgical treatments have long been a part of pregnancy care. However, recent developments in this area, including the increasing routinisation of sophisticated antenatal ultrasound screening and the introduction of treatments including fetal surgery, may mark a shift in this specialty. The paper explores such shifts from the perspectives of medical and midwifery practitioners working in two Fetal Medicine Units. It examines the apparent effects of the orientation of fetal medicine on prevalent conceptualisations of the maternal‐fetal relationship, and some of the consequences of this. It is argued that new forms of uncertainty, including complex risk and diagnostic information, and uncertain prognostic predictions set within the rhetoric of non‐directive counselling and women's choice, are leading to unprecedented ethical dilemmas within this area. More widespread debate about such potential dilemmas needs to take place before, rather than following their introduction.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Framing the fetus in medical work: rituals and practicesSocial Science & Medicine, 2005
- Aiming towards “moral equilibrium”: health care professionals’ views on working within the morally contested field of antenatal screeningJournal of Medical Ethics, 2004
- Too many choices? Hospital and community staff reflect on the future of prenatal screeningSocial Science & Medicine, 2002
- Innovative Health Technologies and the Social: Redefining Health, Medicine and the BodyCurrent Sociology, 2002
- Is nondirectiveness possible within the context of antenatal screening and testing?Social Science & Medicine, 2002
- Conflicting perceptions of the fetus: Person, patient, 'nobody', commodity?New Genetics and Society, 2001
- Medical paternalism and the fetusJournal of Medical Ethics, 2001
- Third trimester abortion: is compassion enough?BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics & Gynaecology, 1999
- The rise of surveillance medicineSociology of Health & Illness, 1995
- Beyond Conception1989