Abstract
Investment funds marketed as “sustainable” or “ESG” (Environmental, Social and Governance) have proliferated in recent years. In the wake of this trend, skepticism is looming among the public over the trustworthiness of these financial actors and the distinctiveness of their investment practices compared to those of regular actors. Using a panel data set of 2,042 U.S. equity mutual funds, we empirically examine whether such funds actually differ from their conventional peers in terms of investment strategies, the returns they offer to their investors, and the capital flows they attract from the latter over the period 2013q1–2018q4. We further show how it evolves over time, and in response to climate concerns. Regarding investment strategies, our findings indicate that the portfolio compositions of high-ESG funds differ from those of their conventional peers and, more surprisingly, from each other. As time goes by, high-ESG and conventional groups become increasingly similar, while high-ESG portfolios become more homogeneous. In terms of financial performance, our results suggest that, on average, high-ESG funds underperform their conventional peers. However, they show greater resilience to climate risk, erasing the gap in financial performance between the two groups when climate risk surges. Finally, our findings provide evidence that climate risk increases capital flows, especially into less distinctive mutual funds. Nevertheless, we cannot find any difference in capital flows between high-ESGs and conventional funds.

This publication has 61 references indexed in Scilit: