We study whether thank-you communications charities send to past donors should include a call to action (CTA), a direct request to give again, and show that the answer depends on whether the donor has already given in the current giving cycle. A CTA can clarify desired behavior and increase compliance, but may backfire when it asks donors to give beyond their typical cadence and violates expectations about when requests are appropriate. In a field experiment with 35,077 prior donors to a major Indian charity, we compare thank-you letters that include a CTA with otherwise identical letters without one. Response rates are low, as is typical in direct mail, with 0.69% of recipients giving. Among donors who have not yet given in the current cycle, the CTA significantly increases giving; among those who have already given, the CTA is associated with lower giving. Aggregate evaluations therefore mask heterogeneity in the CTA's effects. Because giving status within the current cycle is readily observable, charities can use it to target calls to action more effectively and improve expected fundraising revenue.