Is Structural Equation Modeling Advantageous for the Genetic Improvement of Multiple Traits?
Open Access
- 1 July 2013
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Genetics
- Vol. 194 (3) , 561-572
Abstract
Structural equation models (SEMs) are multivariate specifications capable of conveying causal relationships among traits. Although these models offer insights into how phenotypic traits relate to each other, it is unclear whether and how they can improve multiple-trait selection. Here, we explored concepts involved in SEMs, seeking for benefits that could be brought to breeding programs, relative to the standard multitrait model (MTM) commonly used. Genetic effects pertaining to SEMs and MTMs have distinct meanings. In SEMs, they represent genetic effects acting directly on each trait, without mediation by other traits in the model; in MTMs they express overall genetic effects on each trait, equivalent to lumping together direct and indirect genetic effects discriminated by SEMs. However, in breeding programs the goal is selecting candidates that produce offspring with best phenotypes, regardless of how traits are causally associated, so overall additive genetic effects are the matter. Thus, no information is lost in standard settings by using MTM-based predictions, even if traits are indeed causally associated. Nonetheless, causal information allows predicting effects of external interventions. One may be interested in predictions for scenarios where interventions are performed, e.g., artificially defining the value of a trait, blocking causal associations, or modifying their magnitudes. We demonstrate that with information provided by SEMs, predictions for these scenarios are possible from data recorded under no interventions. Contrariwise, MTMs do not provide information for such predictions. As livestock and crop production involves interventions such as management practices, SEMs may be advantageous in many settings.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Inferring causal phenotype networks using structural equation modelsGenetics Selection Evolution, 2011
- An application of change-point recursive models to the relationship between litter size and number of stillborns in pigs1Journal of Animal Science, 2010
- Searching for Recursive Causal Structures in Multivariate Quantitative Genetics Mixed ModelsGenetics, 2010
- Modeling relationships between calving traits: a comparison between standard and recursive mixed modelsGenetics Selection Evolution, 2010
- Exploring Biological Relationships Between Calving Traits in Primiparous Cattle with a Bayesian Recursive ModelGenetics, 2009
- Exploration of lagged relationships between mastitis and milk yield in dairy cows using a Bayesian structural equation Gaussian-threshold modelGenetics Selection Evolution, 2008
- Analysis of Litter Size and Average Litter Weight in Pigs Using a Recursive ModelGenetics, 2007
- Quantitative Genetic Models for Describing Simultaneous and Recursive Relationships Between PhenotypesThis article is dedicated to Arthur B. Chapman, teacher and mentor of numerous animal breeding students and disciple and friend of Sewall Wright.Genetics, 2004
- Attenuating effects of preferential treatment with Student-t mixed linear models: a simulation studyGenetics Selection Evolution, 1998
- The Statistical Implications of a System of Simultaneous EquationsEconometrica, 1943