Comparação entre diferentes modelos de periodização sobre a força e espessura muscular em uma sequência dos menores para os maiores grupamentos musculares

Authors:

Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Studies comparing periodization models in sequences that begin with small muscle group and progressed toward large muscle group in untrained subjects in resistance training are scarce. OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of ondulatory periodization and linear periodization models on maximum strength and muscular hypertrophy in a muscle group increasing exercise sequence. METHODS: Twenty-nine men with no experience in RT were randomly assigned into three groups: ondulatory periodization (OP, n = 10), linear periodization (LP, n = 13), and control group (CG, n = 9). The individuals performed 1RM tests in four exercises: biceps curl (BC), triceps extension (TE), lat pull down (LPD) and bench press (BP) and evaluations of maximum voluntary isometric contraction (MVIC), muscle thickness of elbow flexors (EF) and elbow extensors (EE) before and after the 12 weeks of training were carried out. The OP group varied in volume and intensity on a daily basis, while LP group varied every four weeks. The CG did not perform ST. A two-way ANOVA with repeated measures and the effect size (ES) were used to analyze muscle thickness, 1RM load improvement in each of the four exercises and the MVIC between groups. RESULTS: The major findings of this study were: 1) OP showed major ES for 1RM of BC and TE and for muscle thickness of EF and EE when compared with LP. 3) The ES data did not show significant differences for BP and LPD which finished the training session. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that both periodization models were efficient at improving strength gains and muscular growth. However, ES data show that OP promotes major gains in strength for exercises that are positioned at the beginning of the session and hypertrophy. Keywords: resistance training, strength testing, muscle hypertrophy, periodization. INTRODUCTION Periodization of physical training refers to the manipulation of the methodological variables of the physical training divided in logical phases and has the aim to perform specific adjustments for physical performance increase and prevention of overtraining 1 . The use of training periodization in resistance training (RT) has become considerably popular in the last years. Currently, elite athletes, bodybuilders and health clubs goers use physical training periodization in RT with the aim to improve performance 2,3 . Concerning the increase of muscular strength, when RT programs with linear periodization are compared (LP, which performs variations in training volume and intensity in monthly periods) and not periodized programs (which do not present variations in intensity, number of series and repetitions and recovery interval between series and exercises) higher strength gain was observed after performance of RT programs with LP, when compared with not periodized programs 1 . Besides the comparison of LP and not periodized programs, other authors 4-7 evaluated new ways of alternate the RT variables with a periodization model which was named ondulatory periodization (OP). The OP hypothesis is that higher alternance frequency of volume and intensity (performed at every session) provides more frequent stimulus alterations, which cause the neuromuscular system to adapt to each training session and avoid stagnation of the muscular strength increase 6 . Some studies which compared the LP and OP effects demonstrated higher strength, muscular power and local muscle resistance gain, in OP programs when compared with LP programs 4,6,8-10 ; however, other studies did not demonstrate significant differences between the two systems 5,7,11 . The higher maximal strength gain found in OP programs is attributed to higher manipulation of training volume and intensity, which allows better stimulus/recovery ratio and prevention of overtraining , which may be caused by the linear intensity increase of the training used in LP 1,4,6,8-10,12-15 . The studies which did not find differences between LP and OP attribute the strength gain to the total volume training and suggest that LP is used in training programs which have the aim a physical performance peak 7,11 . Recent studies 5-7 of the LP and OP models indicate the need for further investigation, especially when the previously described models are compared. Additionally, studies comparing periodization models in individuals not trained in RT are scarce, and few of them verified muscular alterations such muscle volume 5,9 . Another important factor is that all the studies which compared periodization models used sessions with exercise sequences following from large to small muscle group 5,7,9 and the exercises order may interfere in the increase of muscle strength 16 . Thus, no previous study has verified the LP and OP influence in a sequence from small to large muscle group; therefore, the aim of the present study was to compare the OP and LP effect on maximal strength and muscle hypertrophy in a performance sequence of exercises from small to large muscle groups. Our hypothesis is that the OP will be more efficient than the LP in improving the analyzed dependent variables. MATERIALS AND METHODS Sample Thirty-two men, students from the Brazilian Marine corps sergeant’s course, were randomly distributed in three groups. All of them were physically active and performed calisthenic and aerobic exercises. All individuals reported not to have experience in RT. The fact the individuals were participating in the formation course of the Brazilian Navy sergeants was important so that the individuals had a similar daily routine during the study period. The first group (OP, n = 10) trained using OP with daily overload and number of repetitions maximum variation (RM). The second group (LP, n = 13) used LP starting between 12 and 15 RM on the first training weeks and ending with 3 to 5 RM on the last four weeks. The third group was control (CG, n = 9) and remained performing regular military physical activity program during 12 weeks, but did not perform the RT program. The comparison of the CG results was important to verify whether the military physical training significantly interfered in the maximum strength and muscle hypertrophy. The inclusion criteria of the study were: a) to be physically active, but not be experienced in RT; b) to be military and student from the formation course in sergeants during the experimental protocol; c) not to perform any kind of regular physical activity during the study period, except for the RT prescribed and the military physical training; d) not to have any functional limitation for the RT or for performance of the 1RM test; e) not to present any medical condition which could influence on the physical training program; f) not to use any nutritional supplementation during the study period. All the subjects signed a consent form for participation in the research and were informed about tests and training protocol procedures to be performed during the study period. The study was approved by the Ethics Committee of the Clementino Fraga Filho Hospital, from the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil, under protocol number 014/018. One-repetition maximum test (1RM) After two weeks of familiarization with the exercises in the RT session, in a total of four sessions, all participants performed two sessions of 1RM test with interval of 48 to 72 hours between sessions. The 1RM tests were performed for all exercises using alternate order. The evaluated exercises were the same used in the training program: biceps curl, (BC), triceps extension (TE), lat pull down (LPD) and bench press (BP). On the first day, the 1RMtests were performed and 48 to 72 hours later, the tests were repeated to determine the loads reproducibility. The highest load obtained in the tests was used for statistical analysis. None exercise was performed between the 1RM tests to avoid interference in the results. The 1RM test protocol was previously described 17 . In order to minimize the errors during the 1RM tests, the following strategies were adopted: a) standard instructions about the test procedures were given to the participants; b) the participants received instructions about the performance technique of the exercises; c) all individuals received verbal encouragement during the tests; d) weight of all free weight, plaques and bars used was verified on a precision scale. The 1RM load was determined through most of five attempts for each exercise, with interval of five minutes between attempts and 10 minutes between exercises. After the 12 weeks of training, the 1RM test was conducted in a similar way to the pre-training moment with the aim to compare it with the loads obtained in the pre-test. Maximal voluntary isometric contraction (MVIC) The MVIC test was previously described 18,19 . Maximal load isometric test was used for the elbow flexors (EF) and elbow extensors (EE). For the EF, the individuals remained seated with right elbow flexed at 90 degrees. For the EE, the individual remained at dorsal decubitus with shoulder and right elbow flexed at 90 degrees. After verbal command, the individual performed the MVIC for eight seconds. The maximal load considered was the maximum value obtained in the test, measured in kilograms-strength. The wrist was wrapped with a band attached to a rigid and non-flexible cable, connected to a strength transducer attached to the ground. Muscular thickness measurements Muscle thickness (MT) was evaluated with an ultrasound device (US) model EUB-405, with linear transducer and matrix of 512 elements, with excitement frequency of 7.5 MHz, depth resolution of 65 mm and lateral resolution of 80.3 mm. Gel was used for acoustic attachment and to avoid depression on the skin surface. Circumference of right arm (CIR) was measured at 60% of the arm length (L), defined as the distance between the acromion process of the scapula and the lateral epicondyle of the humerus with the individuals standing and wit harms

This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit: