Risky Business or Competitive Power? Supplier Involvement in Japanese Product Design
Authors:
- S. Nazli WastiSWS. Nazli Wasti
- Jeffrey K. LikerJLJeffrey K. Liker
- 1 September 1997
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Product Innovation Management
- Vol. 14 (5) , 337-355
Abstract
Notwithstanding the alleged risks of outsourcing design work, leading manufacturers in the Japanese automotive industry collaborate closely with their key suppliers. Despite widespread recognition of the effectiveness of these close‐knit supplier networks, however, little research exists on the factors that affect the purchase of design work from suppliers.S. Nazli Wasti and Jeffrey K. Liker fill this gap by exploring the factors that affect Japanese automotive firms' purchase of design work from their component suppliers. Using data from a survey of 122 Japanese automotive component suppliers, their study addresses two key questions. First, what factors lead Japanese buyers to involve some suppliers heavily in design while giving others relatively little control over design decisions? And second, does the Japanese practice of involving suppliers in design offer performance benefits? The study focuses on first‐tier suppliers of parts, assemblies, and complete subsystems (e.g., audio, fuel and emissions, heating and air conditioning). The study does not include suppliers of raw materials and chemicals, assembly and processing equipment, indirect materials, tooling and dies, computers and software, or engineering and business consulting services.The study breaks down the broad concept of supplier involvement in design work into three measurable elements: the extent to which the supplier influences decision‐making during the early stages of product development; the amount of control the buyer retains over the design; and the frequency of design‐related communication between the buyer and the supplier. Factors that have a positive effect on the level of supplier involvement among the companies studied include technological uncertainty of the component and the supplier's in‐house technical capabilities. For companies in the study, the level of competition in the supplier market has a negative effect on the degree of supplier involvement in design.The responses indicate that supplier involvement offers performance benefits for both the supplier and the buyer. For the supplier firms studied, increased involvement in the design process permits greater focus on design for manufacturability (DFM). And of course, supplier‐generated design improvements clearly benefit the buyers, allowing these firms to capitalize on the experience and the insight that their suppliers have regarding the parts that they supply.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Transplanted Organizations: The Transfer of Japanese Industrial Organization to the U.S.American Sociological Review, 1991
- Comparative Economic Organization: The Analysis of Discrete Structural AlternativesAdministrative Science Quarterly, 1991
- Alliances in Industrial Purchasing: The Determinants of Joint Action in Buyer-Supplier RelationshipsJournal of Marketing Research, 1990
- Manufacturer-supplier relationships in Japan and the concept of relation-specific skillJournal of the Japanese and International Economies, 1989
- Agency Theory: An Assessment and ReviewAcademy of Management Review, 1989
- Networks: Between markets and hierarchiesStrategic Management Journal, 1986
- The Contractual Framework for Parts Supply in the Japanese Automotive IndustryJapanese Economic Studies, 1985
- Supplier Switching Costs and Vertical Integration in the Automobile IndustryThe Bell Journal of Economics, 1982
- The Economics of Organization: The Transaction Cost ApproachAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1981
- Educational Organizations as Loosely Coupled SystemsAdministrative Science Quarterly, 1976