ON QUANTIFYING TOLERANCE OF HERBIVORY FOR COMPARATIVE ANALYSES
- 1 September 2008
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution
- Vol. 62 (9) , 2429-2434
Abstract
As the evolutionary importance of plant tolerance of herbivory is increasingly appreciated, more and more studies are not just measuring a plant's tolerance, but are comparing tolerance among plant genotypes, populations, species, and environments. Here, we suggest that caution must be taken in such comparative studies in the choice of measurement scales (and data transformations) for damage levels and plant performance. We demonstrate with a simple scenario of two plant groups of equal tolerance how the choice of scales can lead one to infer that the first group is more tolerant, the second group is more tolerant, or the two groups are equally tolerant-using the identical dataset. We conclude that to make reliable, logically consistent inferences when comparing tolerances among groups of plants, damage and performance should both be on an additive scale or both on a multiplicative scale.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Statistical convenience vs biological insight: consequences of data transformation for the analysis of fitness variation in heterogeneous environmentsNew Phytologist, 2005
- PREDICTORS OF MALE AND FEMALE TOLERANCE TO INSECT HERBIVORY IN RAPHANUS RAPHANISTRUMEcology, 2003
- Diffuse Selection on Resistance to Deer Herbivory in the Ivyleaf Morning Glory,Ipomoea hederaceaThe American Naturalist, 2001
- Genetic Constraints and Selection Acting on Tolerance to Herbivory in the Common Morning Glory Ipomoea purpureaThe American Naturalist, 1999
- Regrowth following ungulate herbivory in Ipomopsis aggregata : geographic evidence for overcompensationOecologia, 1999
- Genetic variation in resistance and tolerance to insect herbivory in Salix cordataEcological Entomology, 1997
- A Comparison of the Impacts of Leaf‐ And Sap‐Feeding Insects on Growth and Allocation of GoldenrodEcology, 1993
- Contrasting the Tolerance of Wild and Domesticated Tomatoes to Herbivory: Agroecological ImplicationsEcological Applications, 1993
- Type I Error Rates and Power Estimates of Selected Parametric and Nonparametric Tests of ScaleJournal of Educational Statistics, 1987
- Resistance of Plants to InsectsAnnual Review of Entomology, 1958