Towards a Systematic Understanding of How to Institutionally Design Scientific Advisory Committees: A Conceptual Framework and Introduction to a Special Journal Issue
Open Access
- 27 September 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Global Challenges
- Vol. 2 (9) , 1800020
Abstract
Scientifically‐derived insights are often held as requirements for defensible policy choices. Scientific advisory committees (SACs) figure prominently in this landscape, often with the promise of bringing scientific evidence to decision‐makers. Yet, there is sparse and scattered knowledge about what institutional features influence the operations and effectiveness of SACs, how these design choices influence subsequent decision‐making, and the lessons learned from their application. The consequences of these knowledge gaps are that SACs may not be functioning as effectively as possible. The articles in this special journal issue of Global Challenges bring together insights from experts across several disciplines, all of whom are committed to improving SACs' effectiveness worldwide. The aim of the special issue is to inform future SAC design in order to help maximize the application of high‐quality scientific research for the decisions of policymakers, practitioners, and the public alike. In addition to providing an overview of the special issue and a summary of each article within it, this introductory essay presents a definition of SACs and a conceptual framework for how different institutional features and contextual factors affect three proximal determinants of SACs' effectiveness, namely the quality of advice offered, the relevance of that advice, and its legitimacy.Keywords
Funding Information
- Norges Forskningsråd (#234608)
- Canadian Institutes of Health Research
- Ontario Ministry of Research, Innovation and Science
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Conceptualizing credibility, relevance and legitimacy for evaluating the effectiveness of science–policy interfaces: Challenges and opportunitiesScience and Public Policy, 2015
- Decisions on WHO's essential medicines need more scrutinyBMJ, 2014
- A systematic review of barriers to and facilitators of the use of evidence by policymakersBMC Health Services Research, 2014
- How experts are chosen to inform public policy: Can the process be improved?Health Policy, 2013
- Balancing credibility, relevance and legitimacy: A critical assessment of trade-offs in science-policy interfacesScience and Public Policy, 2013
- Research Ethics Boards: Reply from Trudo Lemmens and Carl ElliottPLOS Medicine, 2006
- Expert panels evaluating research: decision-making and sources of biasResearch Evaluation, 2004
- Use of Technical Expert Panels: Applications to Probabilistic Seismic Hazard Analysis*Risk Analysis, 1998
- The utilization of scientific information in the management of estuarine ecosystemsOcean & Coastal Management, 1994
- Chance and Consensus in Peer ReviewScience, 1981