A comparison of IROC and ACDS on‐site audits of reference and non‐reference dosimetry
Authors:
Open Access
- 8 September 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 46 (12) , 5878-5887
Abstract
Purpose: Consistency between different international quality assurance groups is important in the progress toward similar standards and expectations in radiotherapy dosimetry around the world, and in the context of consistent clinical trial data from international trial participants. This study compares the dosimetry audit methodology and results of two international quality assurance groups performing a side‐by‐side comparison at the same radiotherapy department, and interrogates the ability of the audits to detect deliberately introduced errors.Methods: A comparison of the core dosimetry components of reference and non‐reference audits was conducted by the Imaging and Radiation Oncology Core (IROC, Houston, USA) and the Australian Clinical Dosimetry Service (ACDS, Melbourne, Australia). A set of measurements were conducted over 2 days at an Australian radiation therapy facility in Melbourne. Each group evaluated the reference dosimetry, output factors, small field output factors, percentage depth dose (PDD), wedge, and off‐axis factors according to their standard protocols. IROC additionally investigated the Electron PDD and the ACDS investigated the effect of heterogeneities. In order to evaluate and compare the performance of these audits under suboptimal conditions, artificial errors in percentage depth dose (PDD), EDW, and small field output factors were introduced into the 6 MV beam model to simulate potential commissioning/modeling errors and both audits were tested for their sensitivity in detecting these errors.Results: With the plans from the clinical beam model, almost all results were within tolerance and at an optimal pass level. Good consistency was found between the two audits as almost all findings were consistent between them. Only two results were different between the results of IROC and the ACDS. The measurements of reference FFF photons showed a discrepancy of 0.7% between ACDS and IROC due to the inclusion of a 0.5% nonuniformity correction by the ACDS. The second difference between IROC and the ACDS was seen with the lung phantom. The asymmetric field behind lung measured by the ACDS was slightly (0.3%) above the ACDS's pass (optimal) level of 3.3%. IROC did not detect this issue because their measurements were all assessed in a homogeneous phantom. When errors were deliberately introduced neither audit was sensitive enough to pick up a 2% change to the small field output factors. The introduced PDD change was flagged by both audits. Similarly, the introduced error of using 25° wedge instead of 30° wedge was detectible in both audits as out of tolerance.Conclusions: Despite different equipment, approach, and scope of measurements in on‐site audits, there were clear similarities between the results from the two groups. This finding is encouraging in the context of a global harmonized approach to radiotherapy quality assurance and dosimetry audit.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Cancer Institute
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Dosimetric end-to-end tests in a national audit of 3D conformal radiotherapyPhysics and Imaging in Radiation Oncology, 2018
- A multinational audit of small field output factors calculated by treatment planning systems used in radiotherapyPhysics and Imaging in Radiation Oncology, 2018
- Radiation Therapy Deficiencies Identified During On-Site Dosimetry Visits by the Imaging and Radiation Oncology Core Houston Quality Assurance CenterInternational Journal of Radiation Oncology - Biology - Physics (IJROBP), 2017
- The role of dosimetry audit in lung SBRT multi-centre clinical trialsPhysica Medica, 2017
- Pencil Beam Algorithms Are Unsuitable for Proton Dose Calculations in LungInternational Journal of Radiation Oncology - Biology - Physics (IJROBP), 2017
- Investigation of error detection capabilities of phantom, EPID and MLC log file based IMRT QA methodsJournal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics, 2017
- Agreement Between Institutional Measurements and Treatment Planning System Calculations for Basic Dosimetric Parameters as Measured by the Imaging and Radiation Oncology Core-HoustonInternational Journal of Radiation Oncology - Biology - Physics (IJROBP), 2016
- National dosimetric audit network finds discrepancies in AAA lung inhomogeneity correctionsPhysica Medica, 2015
- Institutional Patient-specific IMRT QA Does Not Predict Unacceptable Plan DeliveryInternational Journal of Radiation Oncology - Biology - Physics (IJROBP), 2014
- Algorithms Used in Heterogeneous Dose Calculations Show Systematic Differences as Measured With the Radiological Physics Center's Anthropomorphic Thorax Phantom Used for RTOG CredentialingInternational Journal of Radiation Oncology - Biology - Physics (IJROBP), 2013