Metagenomic Analysis of Postmortem Cardiac Tissue for Diagnosing Fatal Viral Myocarditis: A Pilot Study

Authors:
  • MSMaud Salmona
    Maud Salmona
  • JMJustine Murano
    Justine Murano
  • SMSéverine Mercier-Delarue
    Séverine Mercier-Delarue
  • DCDomitille Callon
    Domitille Callon
  • ARAbdeljalil Senhaji Rachik
    Abdeljalil Senhaji Rachik
  • AGAurélien Guedra
    Aurélien Guedra
  • MGMarie Glenet
    Marie Glenet
  • FBFatma Berri
    Fatma Berri
  • YNYohan N&Apos;Guyen
    Yohan N&Apos;Guyen

Abstract
Background: Metagenomic next-generation sequencing may provide diagnostic information when conventional assays are inconclusive. Its role in myocarditis remains largely unexplored because cardiac samples are rarely available and viral burdens may be low.Objectives: To assess the diagnostic performance of metagenomic analysis in postmortem cardiac tissue from sudden cardiac death cases and compare it with viral RT-qPCR.Study design: Fresh frozen heart samples from 19 sudden cardiac death cases and 7 controls were analyzed. Cases included 14 patients without coronary artery disease and 5 with coronary artery disease. Controls were individuals who died from suicide or road traffic accidents and had no structural heart disease. Shotgun metagenomic sequencing and viral-enriched sequencing using the Illumina Virus Surveillance Panel were performed on cardiac nucleic acid extracts. Concordance with RT-qPCR was assessed using Cohen’s kappa coefficient.Results: Overall concordance between RT-qPCR and metagenomic approaches was poor. Neither method detected any viral target in patients with genetically confirmed or suspected channelopathies. In myocarditis cases, there was no agreement for enterovirus detection. For parvovirus B19, agreement was absent with shotgun metagenomics and slight with viral-enriched sequencing (kappa = 0.15). For HHV-6, agreement was slight with shotgun metagenomics (kappa = 0.25) and absent with viral-enriched sequencing. Additional viral sequences, including EBV and TTV, were detected by metagenomics, but their clinical significance remains uncertain.Conclusions: In this pilot study, metagenomic analysis of postmortem cardiac tissue showed limited added value and did not improve the etiologic diagnosis of presumed viral myocarditis.