One thing leads to another: the cascade of obligations when researchers report genetic research results to study participants
- 15 February 2012
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal of Human Genetics
- Vol. 20 (8) , 837-843
Abstract
Even as debate continues about the putative obligation to proactively report genetic research results to study participants, there is an increasing need to attend to the obligations that might cascade from any initial report. We conducted an international, quasi-experimental survey of researchers involved in autism spectrum disorders (ASD) and cystic fibrosis (CF) genetics to explore perceived obligations to ensure updated information or relevant clinical care subsequent to any initial communication of research results, and factors influencing these attitudes. 5-point Likert scales of dis/agreement were analyzed using descriptive and multivariate statistics. Of the 343 respondents (44% response rate), large majorities agreed that in general and in a variety of hypothetical research contexts, research teams that report results should ensure that participants gain subsequent access to updated information (74–83%) and implicated clinical services (79–87%). At the same time, researchers perceived barriers restricting access to relevant clinical care, though this was significantly more pronounced (P<0.001) for ASD (64%) than CF (34%). In the multivariate model, endorsement of cascading obligations was positively associated with researcher characteristics (eg, clinical role/training) and attitudes (eg, perceived initial reporting obligation), and negatively associated with the initial report of less scientifically robust hypothetical results, but unaffected by perceived or hypothetical barriers to care. These results suggest that researchers strongly endorse information and care-based obligations that cascade from the initial report of research results to study participants. In addition, they raise challenging questions about how any cascading obligations are to be met, especially where access challenges are already prevalent.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Not so simple: a quasi-experimental study of how researchers adjudicate genetic research resultsEuropean Journal of Human Genetics, 2011
- A quantitative association study of SLC25A12 and restricted repetitive behavior traits in autism spectrum disordersMolecular Autism, 2011
- What is a meaningful result? Disclosing the results of genomic research in autism to research participantsEuropean Journal of Human Genetics, 2010
- Replication of past candidate loci for common diseases and phenotypes in 100 genome-wide association studiesEuropean Journal of Human Genetics, 2010
- Duty to disclose what? Querying the putative obligation to return research results to participantsJournal of Medical Ethics, 2008
- When research seems like clinical care: a qualitative study of the communication of individual cancer genetic research resultsBMC Medical Ethics, 2008
- Letting the Gene Out of the Bottle: A Comment on Returning Individual Research Results to ParticipantsThe American Journal of Bioethics, 2006
- Reporting genetic results in research studies: Summary and recommendations of an NHLBI working groupAmerican Journal of Medical Genetics Part A, 2006
- ELSI Priorities for Brain ImagingThe American Journal of Bioethics, 2006
- Disclosing Individual Results of Clinical ResearchJAMA, 2005