On the Tragedy of the Modern Condition: The ‘Theologico-Political Problem’ in Carl Schmitt, Leo Strauss, and Hannah Arendt
Author:
- 14 June 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The European Legacy
- Vol. 22 (6) , 697-728
Abstract
This article addresses Eric L. Santner’s claim that “there is more political theology in everyday life than we might have ever thought” by analyzing the “theologico-political problem” in the work of three prominent twentieth-century political thinkers—Carl Schmitt, Leo Strauss, and Hannah Arendt. Schmitt, Strauss, and Arendt share a preoccupation with the crisis of modern political liberalism and confront the theologico-political problem in a similar spirit: although their responses differ dramatically, their individual accounts dwell on the absence of incontestable principles in modern society that can justify life-in-common and the persistence of the political order. Their writings thus engage with the question of the place of “the absolute” in the political realm. In particular, Arendt’s indirect approach to the theologico-political problem is crucial to understanding the radicality of a political world in which traditional certainties can no longer be re-established. The theoretical trajectory I present suggests that the dispersion of political theology in everyday life has a specific corollary: modern politics operates within the tragic and paradoxical nature of its unstable and common origins that cannot be incorporated in exceptionalist versions of the body politic.Keywords
Funding Information
- Deutscher Akademischer Austauschdienst (DAAD)
- Rosa-Luxemburg-Stiftung
This publication has 89 references indexed in Scilit:
- Beyond the Markers of Certainty: Thoughts on Claude Lefort and Leo StraussPerspectives on Political Science, 2011
- Reading Strauss from the StartEuropean Journal of Political Theory, 2010
- Hannah Arendt on the SecularNew German Critique, 2008
- Introduction: Taking Exception to the Exceptiondiacritics, 2007
- Between Decision and Deliberation: Political Paradox in Democratic TheoryAmerican Political Science Review, 2007
- Beyond Strauss, lies, and the war in Iraq: Hannah Arendt’s critique of neoconservatismReview of International Studies, 2007
- Can the Problem of the Theologico-Political be Resolved? Leo Strauss and Claude LefortThesis Eleven, 2006
- From the Act to the DecisionPolitical Theory, 2004
- On a Certain Critique of “Straussianism”The Review of Politics, 1991
- Hannah Arendt and Leo StraussPolitical Theory, 1990