Psychosocial hazards in residential and commercial construction: a mixed-methods comparison of demands, resources and distress
Open Access
- 4 August 2026
- journal article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management
- Vol. 33 (15) , 812-832
Abstract
Purpose: This study compares psychosocial hazards across residential and commercial construction settings and examines whether sector context conditions the relationship between job demands and psychological distress. Design/methodology/approach: A sequential mixed-methods design was used, integrating survey data from 1,450 construction workers with interviews from 30 workers across residential and commercial sites. Quantitative analyses examined sector differences in psychosocial demands and resources using MANOVA, and moderation analysis tested whether sector type altered the association between psychosocial demands and distress. Qualitative data were thematically analysed to interpret sector differences. Findings: Sector differences were modest; only three psychosocial hazards differed significantly. Supervisor relationship conflict showed a sector-specific association with psychological distress, significant for commercial workers only. Qualitative findings indicate residential workers experienced conflict as brief/relational, whereas commercial workers described continuous, workflow-embedded supervision. Time pressure and external stressors related to finances and family were consistent across sectors. Overall, organisational structures shape how psychosocial hazards are experienced and how conflict translates into distress. Research limitations/implications: Findings are based on an imbalanced sample, with a smaller residential cohort, and cross-sectional data, limiting generalisability and causal inference. Practical implications: Psychosocial risk management should be tailored to sector context, focussed on supervisory practices and how conflict is structured/ experienced across environments. Originality/value: This study provides one of the first direct quantitative comparisons of sector-specific psychosocial conditions in construction, offering mixed-methods evidence that demand–strain relationships may be context-dependent, particularly regarding supervisory dynamics.Keywords
Funding Information
- MATES in Construction (Queensland—Northern Territory) Griffith University Project (#03/07/8259, 2024)
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- People at Work--Construction2024
- Supervisor-worker relationships and the work environment: Development and validation of a construction specific measureSafety Science, 2024
- Limitations to the BIM-based safety management practices in residential construction projectEnvironmental Challenges, 2024
- The relationship between psychosocial hazards and mental health in the construction industry: A meta-analysisSafety Science, 2022
- Assessment of subjective workplace well-being of construction workers: A bottom-up approachJournal of Building Engineering, 2021
- Workforce development: understanding task-level job demands-resources, burnout, and performance in unskilled construction workersSafety Science, 2020
- Differences in safety training among smaller and larger construction firms with non-native workers: Evidence of overlapping vulnerabilitiesSafety Science, 2018
- Work safety climate and safety practices among immigrant Latino residential construction workersAmerican Journal of Industrial Medicine, 2012
- Use of attitude congruence to identify safety interventions for small residential buildersConstruction Management and Economics, 2011
- Issues in Subcontracting PracticeJournal of Construction Engineering and Management, 2005