Plea Bargaining Policy and State District Court Caseloads: An Interrupted Time Series Analysis
Authors:
- Malcolm D. HolmesMHMalcolm D. Holmes
- Howard C. DaudistelHDHoward C. Daudistel
- William A. TaggartWTWilliam A. Taggart
- 1 January 1992
- journal article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Law & Society Review
- Vol. 26 (1) , 139-159
Abstract
Questions about the relation of court caseloads to plea bargaining practices generate much controversy but little sophisticated empirical research. Here we examine the effects of a 1975 felony plea bargaining ban in the Texas district courts in El Paso. Relying on a quasi-experimental interrupted time series model with annual data for 1968–83, we test the hypothesis that the discontinuance of plea bargaining negatively affects court caseloads, specifically the proportion of cases going to jury trial and the disposition rate. We also examine conviction rate, exploring whether the existence of plea bargaining encourages prosecutors to accept weak cases. We find a considerable increase in the proportion of cases going to jury trial immediately after the ban's implementation and a substantial but gradual decrease in the disposition rate. The jury trial rate contributed substantially to the disposition rate decline. The conviction rate was generally unaffected by the ban, although it became more consistent after the ban. Overall our findings suggest that the ban on explicit plea bargaining did affect the district courts' ability to move the felony docket efficiently.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- An aggregate-level examination of the caseload pressure hypothesisJournal of Quantitative Criminology, 1989
- USING LINEAR TREND MODELS TO ANALYZE POLICY IMPACTReview of Policy Research, 1987
- Official Reactions to Hispanic Defendants in the SouthwestJournal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 1985
- COURT CASELOADS, PLEA BARGAINS, AND CRIMINAL SANCTIONS: THE EFFECTS OF SECTION 17 P.C. IN CALIFORNIA*Criminology, 1985
- The Emergent Organization of Plea BargainingAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1985
- The effect of evidentiary factors on charge reductionJournal of Criminal Justice, 1983
- The Changing Plea Bargaining DebateCalifornia Law Review, 1981
- ANALYZING POLICY IMPACT: SELECTION OF A LINEAR TREND MODELPolicy Studies Journal, 1980
- The Caseload Controversy and the Study of Criminal CourtsThe Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology (1973-), 1979
- The Prosecutor's Role in Plea BargainingThe University of Chicago Law Review, 1968