An American Führer? Nazi Analogies and the Struggle to Explain Donald Trump
- 4 December 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Central European History
- Vol. 52 (4) , 554-587
Abstract
Ever since Donald Trump announced his candidacy for the US presidency in June 2015, journalists, scholars, and other commentators in the United States have attempted to explain his political success with the aid of historical analogies. In so doing, they have sparked a wider debate about whether the Nazi past helps to make sense of the US present. One group in the debate has contended that Trump's ascent bears a worrisome resemblance to interwar European fascism, especially the National Socialist movement of Adolf Hitler. By contrast, a second group has rejected this comparison and sought analogies for Trump in other historical figures from European and US history. This article surveys the course, and assesses the results, of the debate from its origins up to the present day. It shows that historians of Germany have played a prominent role in helping to make sense of Trump, but notes that their use of Nazi analogies may be distorting, rather than deepening, our understanding of contemporary political trends. By examining the merits and drawbacks of Nazi analogies in present-day popular discourse, the article recommends that scholars draw on both the German and American historical experience in order to best assess the United States's present political movement.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- The End of the World as We Know It?: American Exceptionalism in an Age of DisruptionSociological Forum, 2017
- Donald Trump: Between Election and InaugurationHistory Workshop Journal, 2017
- Trump’s Savage CapitalismWorld Policy Journal, 2017
- Comparing Apples and Oranges? Leading and Misleading Uses of Historical AnalogiesMillennium: Journal of International Studies, 2007
- Erasing the Brown Scare: Referential Afterlife and the Power of Memory TemplatesSocial Problems, 2007
- Rolling the Iron Dice: Historical Analogies and Decisions to Use Military Force in Regional ContingenciesThe Journal of Military History, 2001
- The Five Stages of FascismThe Journal of Modern History, 1998
- Inflation of Symbols: Loss of Values in American CultureCanadian Journal of Sociology, 1993
- What Fascism Is Not: Thoughts on the Deflation of a ConceptThe American Historical Review, 1979
- Before the Deluge: A Portrait of Berlin in the 1920'sThe History Teacher, 1973