Conflating the map with the territory: Challenges for evidence syntheses on homicide in a global context
Open Access
- 21 May 2025
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Sociology
- Vol. 40 (6) , 944-963
Abstract
Homicide is a global burden that is unequal in risk and distribution. However, evidence required for prevention is currently fragmented across different systems of knowledge production, creating challenges in the form of missing data. Viewed through the sociology of quantification and knowledge production, this article provides methodological and ethical reflections on conducting a global systematic review of sex/gender-disaggregated homicide data. In doing so, it highlights epistemological and ontological differences that risk becoming obscured in global, comparative work on violence. The systematic review consisted of a four-step search strategy: electronic database searches, hand searches of statistics, ministry, and police websites, citation tracking, and email survey of statistics offices. Studies were included if they reported prevalence data on homicide which was sex/gender-disaggregated (by victim/offender relationship, sexual aspects, and/or motivation) by both women and men. From 194 WHO-recognised countries, data were available for just under half ( n = 84). However, there were pronounced differences between countries and regions regarding the availability of data. To avoid conflating the ‘map with the territory’ as others argue, this article follows the call from Dalmer for critical knowledge synthesis which builds contestation in to systematic review and recognises evidence in a wider (and unequal) system of knowledge production.Keywords
Funding Information
- Medical Research Council (MR-VO49879-1)
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ethically Driven and Methodologically Tailored: Setting the Agenda for Systematic Reviews in Domestic Violence and AbuseJournal of Family Violence, 2023
- Addressing Data Gaps: Implications for Preventing Domestic HomicideJournal of Family Violence, 2023
- Feminicide and counterdata production: Activist efforts to monitor and challenge gender-related violencePatterns, 2022
- What should equity in global health research look like?The Lancet, 2022
- Lives that Matter: Criminology and Global Security InequalityInternational Criminology, 2021
- Introduction: Of Numbers and Narratives—Indicators in Global Governance and the Rise of a Reflexive Indicator Culture2017
- The global prevalence of intimate partner homicide: a systematic reviewThe Lancet, 2013
- Meta‐Analysis in Criminal Justice and Criminology: What It is, When It's Useful, and What to Watch Out forJournal of Criminal Justice Education, 2010
- A Sociology of QuantificationEuropean Journal of Sociology, 2008
- On ‘Systematic’ Reviews of Research Literatures: A ‘narrative’ response to Evans & BenefieldBritish Educational Research Journal, 2001