Illustrating the power and complexity of a National Longitudinal Superintendent Database through an exploration of cross-state mobility
- 11 June 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Educational Administration
- Vol. ahead-of-p (ahead-of-p) , 302-314
Abstract
Purpose: This paper has three purposes: (1) to underscore the importance of compiling comprehensive data on superintendents, (2) to describe the creation of the National Longitudinal Superintendent Database (NLSD) and (3) to illustrate the value of sustained investment in national longitudinal data by analyzing cross-state superintendent attrition and mobility.Design/methodology/approach: We present descriptive and correlational analyses of the nuances and nature of cross-state superintendent mobility that demonstrate the distinct knowledge-building opportunities afforded by the establishment of an NLSD. We then build on our description of the establishment of the NLSD to discuss the strengths and challenges of developing and sustaining a national superintendent database that incorporates both qualitative and quantitative data and provide recommendations for a path forward to expand the accuracy of and access to superintendent data.Findings: Our findings suggest that superintendent cross-state mobility is higher than that of other educators and that racial and gender inequities persist in these leadership pathways. For example, superintendents who retire, relocate and continue in the role elsewhere are disproportionately white men, while women and Black superintendents are overrepresented among those leaving the profession amid political or contentious environments.Originality/value: By examining the development and utility of the NLSD, this paper contributes a novel, large-scale approach to studying superintendent labor markets across state lines. To our knowledge, this is the first national analysis of cross-state superintendent mobility. In doing so, we demonstrate both the complexity and promise of investing in national longitudinal infrastructure for education leadership, particularly as a tool to uncover and address equity issues in the superintendent workforce.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- What Happened to the K–12 Education Labor Market During COVID? The Acute Need for Better Data SystemsEducation Finance and Policy, 2023
- The Art of Sophisticated Quantitative Description in Higher Education Research2022
- Knowing your audience: understanding urban superintendents' process of framing equitable changeJournal of Educational Administration, 2021
- Principals’ Conceptions of Instructional Leadership and Their Informal Social Networks: An Exploration of the Mechanisms of the MesolevelAmerican Journal of Education, 2016
- Salary, Performance, and Superintendent TurnoverEducational Administration Quarterly, 2016
- School administrators' career mobility to the superintendencyJournal of Educational Administration, 2009
- Superintendent and School Board Member Turnover: Political Versus Apolitical Turnover as a Critical Variable in the Application of the Dissatisfaction TheoryEducational Administration Quarterly, 2003
- Inter‐racial contact and the own‐race bias for face recognition in South Africa and EnglandApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2003
- Sexism, Silence, and Solutions: Women Superintendents Speak Up and Speak OutEducational Administration Quarterly, 2000
- When is Tenure Long Enough? A Historical Analysis of Superintendent Turnover and Tenure in Urban School DistrictsEducational Administration Quarterly, 1996