Methods and mechanisms for measuring and monitoring outcomes from newborn bloodspot screening: a scoping review
Authors:
- Katie ScandrettKSKatie Scandrett
- Jacqueline DinnesJDJacqueline Dinnes
- Breanna MorrisonBMBreanna Morrison
- April CoombeACApril Coombe
- Ridhi AgarwalRARidhi Agarwal
- Isaac Adu AsareIAIsaac Adu Asare
- Phoebe MeadPMPhoebe Mead
- Andy De SouzaASAndy De Souza
- David EllimanDEDavid Elliman
- Silvia LombardoSLSilvia Lombardo
- John MarshallJMJohn Marshall
- Sian Taylor-PhillipsSTSian Taylor-Phillips
Open Access
- 1 January 2026
- journal article
- review article
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health Technology Assessment
- p. 1-48
Abstract
Background: Newborn bloodspot screening offers the potential to detect rare diseases early, enabling timely treatment that can reduce mortality and morbidity. Generating evidence for rare diseases often depends on observational data, making it challenging to formulate recommendations for new screening programmes and evaluate the effectiveness of existing ones. Objective(s): To identify the range of methods and mechanisms used to measure and monitor outcomes from newborn screening programmes using a scoping review. Methods: We included studies published between 2019 and 2024, which evaluated a current or candidate newborn screening programme, or which reported outcomes in screen-detected cases. Studies were categorised into four groups: group 1 reported a comparison and follow-up; group 2 reported a comparison but no follow-up; group 3 reported no comparison with follow-up; and group 4 reported no comparison or follow-up. Data were extracted from a random sample of studies within each group; studies in group 1 were prioritised. Results were reported narratively according to study group. The review was conducted and reported according to current guidance for scoping reviews. Data sources: EMBASE (Ovid), MEDLINE (Ovid) and Science Citation Index (Web of Science – Clarivate). Results: We included 574 primary studies and extracted data from 178. Of the 75 studies in group 1, most compared screen-detected cases with controls (74%). Studies in this group used newborn bloodspot programme databases, registries or record review to identify participants and outcomes; only six (8%) reported use of record linkage. Studies in group 2 ( n = 31) mostly reported comparisons of screening tests (25, 81%). Over half of studies in group 3 ( n = 34) used newborn bloodspot programme databases to identify participants (53%) and outcomes (65%). A similar pattern was seen in the group 4 ( n = 38). Studies reporting follow-up typically relied on retrospective record review or were not well reported. Across all study groups, data on accuracy, epidemiology and genetic variants were common. Studies in group 1 also reported on the effectiveness of newborn bloodspot screening (32/75, 43%), treatment effectiveness (20%) or harms of newborn bloodspot screening (3%). Limitations: Restricting data extraction to a random sample of studies risks missing novel methods or mechanisms. Conclusions: Many studies reported test accuracy metrics and genetic variants in newborn screening. Some data on programme effectiveness were identified, but assessment of potential harms remains limited, and methods for follow-up were poorly reported. Assessment of harms, including overdiagnosis and psychological impact, is crucial to ensuring a net benefit at the population level. Future work: In a second phase of work, an in-depth assessment of studies using different methods and mechanisms will be conducted to identify the extent to which they can provide outcome data to inform the evaluation of ongoing and candidate screening programmes. Funding: This article presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment programme as award number NIHR167910.Keywords
Funding Information
- Health Technology Assessment Programme (NIHR167910)
This publication has 205 references indexed in Scilit:
- Newborn Screening for High-Risk Congenital Heart Disease by Dried Blood Spot Biomarker AnalysisJAMA Network Open, 2024
- Clinical Effectiveness of Newborn Screening for Spinal Muscular AtrophyJAMA Pediatrics, 2024
- Positive impacts of universal newborn screening on the outcome of children with sickle cell disease in the province of Quebec: A retrospective cohort studyeJHaem, 2024
- Clinical events in a long‐term prospective neonatal cohort of children with sickle cell disease: Evidence for a high disease burden without systematic preventive intensification with hydroxyureaAmerican Journal of Hematology, 2023
- Natural History and Real‐World Data in Rare Diseases: Applications, Limitations, and Future PerspectivesThe Journal of Clinical Pharmacology, 2022
- Georgia state spinal muscular atrophy newborn screening experience: Screening assay performance and early clinical outcomesAmerican Journal of Medical Genetics Part C: Seminars in Medical Genetics, 2022
- Small Data Challenges of Studying Rare DiseasesJAMA Network Open, 2020
- Expanded newborn screening for inborn errors of metabolism by tandem mass spectrometry in newborns from Xinxiang city in ChinaJournal of Clinical Laboratory Analysis, 2020
- Impact of Diagnosis and Therapy on Cognitive Function in Urea Cycle DisordersAnnals of Neurology, 2019
- Newborn screening for homocystinurias: Recent recommendations versus current practiceJournal of Inherited Metabolic Disease, 2019