Use of FoxP3+ and cytotoxic CD8+ T lymphocytes to identify a patient subgroup with a favorable prognosis similar to colon cancers with deficient DNA mismatch (dMMR) repair.
460 Background: The immune response has emerged as a strong prognostic factor in colon cancer. Whereas CD8+ T cells mediate antitumor response, regulatory T cells expressing FoxP3+ can antagonize this effect, though prognostic data conflict. These markers have yet to be analyzed with MMR status, which is important since dMMR tumors show enhanced immune response. Methods: CD8+ and FoxP3+ density were analyzed by immunohistochemistry (IHC) in resected stage II and III colon carcinomas (N = 216) from participants in phase III adjuvant 5-fluorouracil-based trials. High vs low immune density was dichotomized at the median. MMR status, determined by IHC or analysis of microsatellite instability, was categorized as dMMR (12%) or proficient MMR (pMMR). Cox models, stratified by study, were adjusted for age, stage, grade and, where noted, MMR. Results: The association of FoxP3+ density with overall survival (OS) differed by CD8+ density (P for interaction = .040). By multivariable analysis, FoxP3+high was significantly associated with improved OS in CD8+low tumors (hazard ratio 0.43 [95% confidence interval 0.19 – 0.95]; P = .030], but not in CD8+high tumors (P = .91). Results were consistent after MMR adjustment. We then determined their prognostic impact in the larger pMMR subset (N = 119). Tumors with high FoxP3+ were associated with improved OS in cases with low, but not high, CD8+ density ( Table ). These patients (FoxP3+high, CD8+low) had similar 5-year OS rates as 107 dMMR cases from parent studies (89% vs 80%; P = .74), despite having distinct clinicopathologic features. Conclusions: The prognostic impact of FoxP3+ T cells depends on CD8+, indicating the importance of analyzing both in combination. High FoxP3+ exerts a paradoxically favorable survival impact, but only when CD8+ is low. Survival in pMMR tumors with high FoxP3+ and low CD8+ was similar to that of dMMR tumors, indicating that a favorable pMMR subset can be identified. [Table: see text]