Abstract
We present a thermodynamic framework, based on the theory of generalized standard materials and an extended principle of virtual power, that delivers a consistent electrochemical formulation unifying disparate phase-field models, including the Cahn-Hilliard reaction model and both hybrid and nonlinear Allen-Cahn reaction models, for the description of dendrite propagation during lithium deposition.Finite-element simulations identify two deposition regimes: (i) an unconstrained regime that produces ramified, fractal morphologies and is well captured by the nonlinear Allen–Cahn (NAC) model at low electrode/electrolyte surface energy; and (ii) in the confined regime, accurately described by the hybrid Allen–Cahn (HAC) formulation, surface energy localizes and regularizes propagation. In this case the Allen–Cahn surface propagation term must be implemented as a surface contribution to the complementary dissipation potential during thermodynamic closure. Furthermore, the free energy must account for the coupling between reactive species in order to ensure physically realistic Li+ concentrations and a correct mass balance over the entire battery cycle. Omission of these closures results in unphysical solutions. These results provide practical guidelines for predictive lithium-battery modeling and highlight the central role of interfacial thermodynamics in dendrite formation.