Abstract
BACKGROUND Individuals experiencing potential breast cancer symptoms increasingly turn to online health communities for information and peer support before receiving a formal diagnosis or initiating treatment. While platforms such as Reddit provide accessible spaces to share lived experiences, patient communication needs evolve across the pre-treatment care trajectory, and concerns remain regarding whether peer-generated responses adequately address specific clinical and emotional concerns. Despite growing interest in online cancer communities, little empirical evidence exists regarding how expressed needs and corresponding peer support vary across distinct pre-treatment phases. OBJECTIVE This study aimed to characterize the communication needs expressed by users and the peer support provided in replies within an online breast health community, and to evaluate the coverage of matching support across four positions in the Model of Pathways to Treatment: Appraisal, Help-seeking, Diagnostic, and Pre-treatment. METHODS A cross-sectional content analysis was conducted using 15,037 public threads posted between August 2022 and December 2025 on Reddit’s r/doihavebreastcancer community. Latent Dirichlet allocation topic modeling identified 10 recurring discussion topics, from which a balanced analytic corpus of 1,000 threads (100 per topic) was selected via stratified purposeful sampling. Two coders independently applied a theory-informed codebook to classify pathway positions, expressed post needs, and support categories in eligible human replies. Chi-square tests, modified Poisson regression with robust standard errors, and topic-stratified bootstrap resampling (2,000 replicates) were used to compare response access and overall support-category coverage across five theoretical need–support mappings. RESULTS Of the 957 threads with an identifiable pathway position, 698 (72.9%) received at least one human reply. Symptom interpretation predominated in Appraisal (81.1%) and Help-seeking (76.9%), whereas medical process information seeking and emotional relief were more frequent in Diagnostic (46.9% and 40.4%, respectively) and Pre-treatment (47.8% and 52.2%, respectively). Human response rates varied significantly across positions (P<.001), peaking at Pre-treatment (65/69, 94.2%). Overall matching support coverage ranged from 16.2% (85/525) for help-seeking encouragement among risk-assessment posts to 73.8% (267/362) for informational support among medical process inquiries. In a post hoc analysis of 100 posts requesting clinical report interpretation, only 32 (32.0%) received a human reply and 13 (13.0%) received informational support. CONCLUSIONS Online breast health forums provide substantial informational and emotional support, yet peer support coverage remains uneven across care stages and communication tasks. While procedural questions are well addressed, critical gaps persist in responding to clinical report interpretation inquiries. As patients increasingly access test results immediately via electronic health portals, these findings highlight specific clinical touchpoints where timely professional explanations and moderated community guidance are most needed.

This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit: