Cumulative False Positive Rates Given Multiple Performance Validity Tests: Commentary on Davis and Millis (2014) and Larrabee (2014)
- 11 November 2014
- journal article
- editorial
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Clinical Neuropsychologist
- Vol. 28 (8) , 1212-1223
Abstract
Controversy has arisen over interpretation of performance validity tests (PVTs) when multiple PVTs are given. Some papers state that more stringent criteria are needed to judge overall performance as invalid, while others argue that concerns about the number of PVTs are overstated and that widely used criteria are appropriate. We examine theoretical models and assumptions, and analyze published data to determine the magnitude of effects implied by theory and observed in practice. Assertions advanced in the primary papers are examined for consistency with the empirical data. Existing theoretical models do not account well for the diverse empirical data, substantial empirical effects remain poorly understood, and the primary papers include assertions that are not empirically supported. The results indicate that: (a) neuropsychology lacks solid theoretical bases for estimating PVT failure rates given various combinations of PVTs, and thus needs to rely on empirical data; (b) existing empirical data fail to support the application of any uniform criteria across the broad range of scenarios involving multiple PVTs; and (c) practice should rely on empirical studies involving combinations of PVTs that have been studied together, in samples clearly appropriate to the individual case, using experimental designs germane to the questions under consideration.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evaluation of the Appropriateness of Multiple Symptom Validity Indices in Psychotic and Non-Psychotic Psychiatric PopulationsThe Clinical Neuropsychologist, 2011
- Interpreting the Meaning of Multiple Symptom Validity Test FailureThe Clinical Neuropsychologist, 2009
- Malingering Scales for the Continuous Recognition Memory Test and the Continuous Visual Memory TestThe Clinical Neuropsychologist, 2009
- Aggregation Across Multiple Indicators Improves the Detection of Malingering: Relationship to Likelihood RatiosThe Clinical Neuropsychologist, 2008
- An inferential confidence interval method of establishing statistical equivalence that corrects Tryon's (2001) reduction factor.Psychological Methods, 2008
- Detection of Malingering Using Atypical Performance Patterns on Standard Neuropsychological TestsThe Clinical Neuropsychologist, 2003
- Noncredible Cognitive Performance in the Context of Severe Brain InjuryThe Clinical Neuropsychologist, 2003
- Diagnostic Criteria for Malingered Neurocognitive Dysfunction: Proposed Standards for Clinical Practice and ResearchThe Clinical Neuropsychologist, 1999
- Neurocognitive deficit in schizophrenia: A quantitative review of the evidence.Neuropsychology, 1998
- Neurocognitive deficit in schizophrenia: A quantitative review of the evidence.Neuropsychology, 1998