Abstract
The article examines the use of electronic evidence in Ukrainian civil proceedings amid the digitalization of justice. It argues that the civil standard of proof—the “balance of probabilities”—is not reducible to percentage thresholds and must be implemented through the verifiability of digital materials: preserving original metadata, recording hash values and timestamps, applying an appropriate electronic signature, and documenting the chain of custody. Drawing on doctrinal analysis, comparative law (the EU, England and Wales, Singapore), and a review of Supreme Court practice, the study shows a gradual crystallization of minimum admissibility criteria for electronic evidence (identification of authors/recipients, ascertainment of content, and the possibility of verifying integrity) and underscores the need to unify approaches. The paper proposes steps to reform procedural legislation: enshrining a “technical minimum” for electronic evidence (metadata, hashes, timestamps, signature/seal); adopting standardized guidance akin to PD 57AD; harmonizing with eIDAS-2; and transforming ESITS from a “transport” layer into a “verification” platform with automated checks and audit trails. This coupling of procedural and technical requirements can improve the quality of judicial decisions—especially their predictability and fairness—by reducing disputes over the authenticity and provenance of digital materials.