Abstract
Games can be a powerful medium for encouraging reflection. Game designers can elect to include reflective elements within games otherwise designed for the mass-market. In order to better understand how mass-market games encourage players to reflect and which game elements were successful or unsuccessful in aiding reflection, we conducted an online survey. This survey was exploratory in nature and asked participants about their feelings towards games that had attempted to include deeper messages as part of gameplay. Inductive thematic analysis on the 139 responses led to identification of elements players valued within games and the creation of four themes underlying the player experience. Beyond the themes, a key takeaway was that games encourage reflection when they provide a space for players to project and explore their own experiences and philosophies, or when games enable implicit conversation between the player and the designer on the message of the game.