Breaking the boundary layer symmetry in turbulent convection using wall geometry
Authors:
- Srikanth ToppaladoddiSTSrikanth Toppaladoddi
- Sauro SucciSSSauro Succi
- John S. WettlauferJWJohn S. Wettlaufer
Preprint
Abstract
We probe the interaction of the boundary layer with the core flow during two-dimensional turbulent Rayleigh-B\'{e}nard convection using numerical simulations and theory. The boundary layer/core flow interaction is manipulated with a sinusoidal top plate of wavelength $\lambda$, which breaks the top/bottom thermal boundary layer symmetry. The roughness wavelength controls the generation of cold plumes and hence the interaction between the thermal boundary layers and the core flow. When $\lambda$ is too large, the planar case is recovered, the plume production decreases and the boundary layer/core flow interaction weakens. However, at intermediate wavelengths, and for Rayleigh numbers ($Ra$) such that the amplitude of the roughness elements is larger than the boundary layer thickness, there is enhanced cold plume production at the tips of the elements. While the interior of the flow is well mixed as in the classical theory of Malkus, the mean temperature is lower than that in the planar case. The central role of the plumes emanating from the tips of the roughness elements is quantified by (a) the thermal correlations as a function of depth, which scale with roughness wavelength and persist well into the interior of the flow, and (b) the mean temperature in the core flow. The exponent in the Nusselt-Rayleigh ($Nu$-$Ra$) scaling law is sensitive to the top plate wavelength, revealing $Nu \sim Ra^{1/3}$ and $Nu \sim Ra^{3/8}$ for two different wavelengths. We present a simple argument for the latter scaling.