On the quality of emission reductions: observed effects of carbon pricing on investments, innovation, and operational shifts. A response to van den Bergh and Savin (2021)
Open Access
- 29 July 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Environmental and Resource Economics
- Vol. 83 (3) , 733-758
Abstract
To meet the Paris Agreement targets, carbon emissions from the energy system must be eliminated by mid-century, implying vast investment and systemic change challenges ahead. In an article in WIREs Climate Change, we reviewed the empirical evidence for effects of carbon pricing systems on technological change towards full decarbonisation, finding weak or no effects. In response, van den Bergh and Savin (2021) criticised our review in an article in this journal, claiming that it is “unfair”, incomplete and flawed in various ways. Here, we respond to this critique by elaborating on the conceptual roots of our argumentation based on the importance of short-term emission reductions and longer-term technological change, and by expanding the review. This verifies our original findings: existing carbon pricing schemes have sometimes reduced emissions, mainly through switching to lower-carbon fossil fuels and efficiency increases, and have triggered weak innovation increases. There is no evidence that carbon pricing systems have triggered zero-carbon investments, and scarce but consistent evidence that they have not. Our findings highlight the importance of adapting and improving climate policy assessment metrics beyond short-term emissions by also assessing thequalityof emission reductions and the progress of underlying technological change.Keywords
Funding Information
- H2020 European Research Council (715132)
- Institute for Advanced Sustainability Studies e.V. (IASS)
This publication has 65 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Environment and Directed Technical ChangeAmerican Economic Review, 2012
- Evidence of Innovation and Diffusion Under Tradable Permit ProgramsInternational Review of Environmental and Resource Economics, 2011
- The role of the regulatory framework for innovation activities: the EU ETS and the German paper industryInternational Journal of Technology, Policy and Management, 2011
- The innovation impact of the EU Emission Trading System — Findings of company case studies in the German power sectorEcological Economics, 2011
- The impact of the EU ETS on the sectoral innovation system for power generation technologies – Findings for GermanyEnergy Policy, 2010
- Abatement and Allocation in the Pilot Phase of the EU ETSEnvironmental and Resource Economics, 2010
- Innovation and diffusion of environmental technology: Industrial NOx abatement in Sweden under refunded emission paymentsEcological Economics, 2009
- Renewable Energy Policies and Technological Innovation: Evidence Based on Patent CountsEnvironmental and Resource Economics, 2009
- The empirical analysis of the determinants for environmental technological change: A research agendaEcological Economics, 2009
- Greenhouse gas emissions in Norway: do carbon taxes work?Energy Policy, 2004