Foiling Kamesian Belletristic Theory in Mid-Eighteenth-Century Scotland
- 2 January 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by The Pennsylvania State University Press in Advances in the History of Rhetoric
- Vol. 22 (1) , 51-72
Abstract
Two disciplinary stories told in mid-eighteenth-century Scotland omit an important plotline. One story is that university teaching of rhetoric transformed into belletristic criticism; another is that ideology and culture transformed to reorient rhetorical theorizing toward everyday practices by non-elites. Untold is a story of how familiar protagonists, such as Hugh Blair, clashed with antagonists, such as John Witherspoon, in the Church of Scotland. Telling that story from the antagonists’ perspectives shows that they reflected on how rhetoric ought to be practiced to manage disagreement in a democratic institution and used what amounted to Kamesian belletrism as a foil.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Political Economy of Rhetorical Style: Hugh Blair's Response to the Civic-Commercial DilemmaQuarterly Journal of Speech, 2008
- Blair's Ideal Orator: Civic Rhetoric and Christian Politeness in Lectures 25-34Rhetorica, 2007
- How We Talk about How We Talk: Communication Theory in the Public InterestJournal of Communication, 2005
- Traditions of Rhetoric, Criticism, and Argument in Kames's Elements of CriticismRhetoric Review, 2003
- The civic function of taste: A re‐assessment of Hugh Blair's rhetorical theoryRhetoric Society Quarterly, 1998
- John Witherspoon's normalizing pedagogy of ethosRhetoric Review, 1997
- The Unpublished Rhetoric Lectures of Robert Watson, Professor of Logic, Rhetoric, and Metaphysics at the University of St. Andrews, 1756–1778Rhetorica, 1994
- John Witherspoon and Scottish Rhetoric and Moral Philosophy in AmericaRhetorica, 1992
- John Witherspoon on eloquenceRhetoric Society Quarterly, 1987
- Rhetoric in the Middle AgesSpeculum, 1942