Weather and Climate Variability May Be Poor Proxies for Climate Change in Farmer Risk Perceptions
Open Access
- 5 August 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Meteorological Society in Weather, Climate, and Society
- Vol. 11 (4) , 697-711
Abstract
Despite long-standing assertions that climate change creates new risk management challenges, the climate change adaptation literature persists in assuming, both implicitly and explicitly, that weather and climate variability are suitable proxies for climate change in evaluating farmers’ risk perceptions and predicting their adaptive responses. This assumption persists in part because there is surprisingly little empirical evidence either way, although case studies suggest that there may be important differences. Here, we use a national survey of South Africa’s commercial grain farmers (n = 389)—similar to their peers in higher-income countries (e.g., North America, Europe, Australia), but without subsidies—to show that they treat weather and climate change risks quite differently. We find that their perceptions of climate change risks are distinct from and, in many regards, oppositional to their perceptions of weather risks. While there seems to be a temporal element to this distinction (i.e., differing concern for short-term vs long-term risks), there are other differences that are better understood in terms of normalcy (i.e., normal vs abnormal relative to historical climate) and permanency (i.e., temporary vs permanent changes). We also find an interaction effect of education and political identity on concern for climate change that is at odds with the well-publicized cultural cognition thesis based on surveys of the American public. Overall, studies that use weather and climate variability as unqualified proxies for climate change are likely to mislead researchers and policymakers about how farmers perceive, interpret, and respond to climate change stimuli.Keywords
Funding Information
- International Development Research Centre (106204-99906075-058)
- Centre for International Governance Innovation (N/A)
- Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (N/A)
- Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada (Insight Grant No. 435-2013-2017)
- University of British Columbia (N/A)
- IODE Canada (N/A)
This publication has 44 references indexed in Scilit:
- Commercial Agriculture inSouthAfrica since 1994: ‘Natural, Simply Capitalism’Journal of Agrarian Change, 2012
- Adaptation to climate change and other stressors among commercial and small-scale South African farmersRegional Environmental Change, 2012
- Individual understandings, perceptions, and engagement with climate change: insights from in‐depth studies across the worldWires Climate Change, 2011
- Adaptation in agriculture: lessons for resilience from eastern regions of New ZealandClimatic Change, 2011
- Adaptation in agriculture: historic effects of heat waves and droughts on UK agricultureInternational Journal of Agricultural Sustainability, 2010
- Adaptation to climate change and climate variability in European agriculture: The importance of farm level responsesEuropean Journal of Agronomy, 2010
- Nationalism and the Farm Novel in South Africa, 1883–2004Journal of Southern African Studies, 2009
- Are there social limits to adaptation to climate change?Climatic Change, 2008
- Adapting agriculture to climate changeProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2007
- Handling Nonresponse In Social ResearchJournal of Agricultural Education, 2001