Sensitivity of Systematic Reserve Selection to Decisions about Scale, Biological Data, and Targets: Case Study from Southern British Columbia
- 10 May 2004
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 18 (3) , 655-666
Abstract
Abstract: The identification of conservation areas based on systematic reserve‐selection algorithms requires decisions related to both spatial and ecological scale. These decisions may affect the distribution and number of sites considered priorities for conservation within a region. We explored the sensitivity of systematic reserve selection by altering values of three essential variables. We used a 1:20,000–scale terrestrial ecosystem map and habitat suitability data for 29 threatened vertebrate species in the Okanagan region of British Columbia, Canada. To these data we applied a reserve‐selection algorithm to select conservation sites while altering selection unit size and shape, features of biodiversity (i.e., vertebrate species), and area conservation targets for each biodiversity feature. The spatial similarity, or percentage overlap, of selected sets of conservation sites identified (1) with different selection units was ≤40%, (2) with different biodiversity features was 59%, and (3) with different conservation targets was ≥94%. Because any selected set of sites is only one of many possible sets, we also compared the conservation value (irreplaceability) of all sites in the region for each variation of the data. The correlations of irreplaceability were weak for different selection units (0.23 ≤r≤ 0.67), strong for different biodiversity features (r= 0.84), and mixed for different conservation targets (r= 0.16; 0.16; 1.00). Because of the low congruence of selected sites and weak correlations of irreplaceability for different selection units, recommendations from studies that have been applied at only one spatial scale must be considered cautiously.Keywords
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Measuring conservation value at fine and broad scales: implications for a diverse and fragmented region, the Agulhas PlainBiological Conservation, 2003
- Spatial analysis of the coincidence of rare vascular plants and landforms in the Carolinian zone of Canada: implications for protectionCanadian Geographies / Géographies canadiennes, 2002
- Conservation of Mammals in Eastern North American Wildlife Reserves: How Small Is Too Small?Conservation Biology, 2001
- Size of selection units for future reserves and its influence on actual vs targeted representation of features: a case study in western New South WalesBiological Conservation, 1998
- Reserve Selection in a Species‐Rich and Fragmented Landscape on the Agulhas Plain, South AfricaConservation Biology, 1997
- Applying Biodiversity Gap Analysis in a Regional Nature Reserve Design for the Edge of Appalachia, Ohio (U.S.A.)Conservation Biology, 1995
- Where Should Nature Reserves Be Located in South Africa? A Snake's PerspectiveConservation Biology, 1995
- Where Should Nature Reserves Be Located in South Africa? A Snake's PerspectiveConservation Biology, 1995
- Scale Dependence of Species Richness Maps∗The Professional Geographer, 1994
- Artificial Nests for Ferruginous and Swainson's HawksThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 1984