Partial Charge Symbols Promote Productive Electrostatic Reasoning in Organic Chemistry
Authors:
- 14 October 2026
- journal article
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Journal of Chemical Education
- Vol. 103 (11) , 6405-6412
Abstract
Students’ conceptions of organic chemistry are often grounded in memorized rules and heuristics, detached from the underlying principles governing molecular behavior. Electrostatics is a foundational determinant of reactivity, yet it is often underutilized in student reasoning due to its implicit nature in commonly used instructional molecular representations. The present study investigates whether representations that explicitly depict electrostatic information prompt students to engage in electrostatic reasoning when identifying electron donor and acceptor sites in polar reactions and how such reasoning relates to task performance. Results indicate that electrostatic explanations are strongly associated with higher accuracy across tasks. Additionally, representations that make electrostatic features explicit increase the likelihood of electrostatic explanations. Overall, the findings suggest that representations influence student performance indirectly by shaping the type of reasoning students employ and that simple electrostatic cues embedded within familiar representations may be sufficient to promote electrostatic explanations and support task success.Keywords
Funding Information
- Division of Undergraduate Education (2142324)
- Royal Society of Chemistry
This publication has 40 references indexed in Scilit:
- Affordances of Electrostatic Potential Maps in Promoting Use of Electronic Features and Causal Reasoning in Organic ChemistryJournal of Chemical Education, 2024
- The Picture Is Not the Point: Toward Using Representations as Models for Making Sense of PhenomenaJournal of Chemical Education, 2022
- Semiotic Modes and Representations of Knowledge2021
- Towards a Definition of Representational Competence2018
- ‘Models of’ versus ‘Models for’Science & Education, 2017
- An investigation of college chemistry students' understanding of structure–property relationshipsJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2013
- Making predictions about chemical reactivity: Assumptions and heuristicsJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2013
- Multimedia Learning of Chemistry2005
- Students Becoming Chemists: Developing Representationl Competence2005
- Electrostatics in chemistryResonance, 1999