On the performances of Intensity Modulated Protons, RapidArc and Helical Tomotherapy for selected paediatric cases
Open Access
- 14 January 2009
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in Radiation Oncology
- Vol. 4 (1) , 2
Abstract
Background: To evaluate the performance of three different advanced treatment techniques on a group of complex paediatric cancer cases. Methods: CT images and volumes of interest of five patients were used to design plans for Helical Tomotherapy (HT), RapidArc (RA) and Intensity Modulated Proton therapy (IMP). The tumour types were: extraosseous, intrathoracic Ewing Sarcoma; mediastinal Rhabdomyosarcoma; metastastis of base of skull with bone, para-nasal and left eye infiltration from Nephroblastoma of right kidney; metastatic Rhabdomyosarcoma of the anus; Wilm's tumour of the left kidney with multiple liver metastases. Cases were selected for their complexity regardless the treatment intent and stage. Prescribed doses ranged from 18 to 53.2 Gy, with four cases planned using a Simultaneous Integrated Boost strategy. Results were analysed in terms of dose distributions and dose volume histograms. Results: For all patients, IMP plans lead to superior sparing of organs at risk and normal healthy tissue, where in particular the integral dose is halved with respect to photon techniques. In terms of conformity and of spillage of high doses outside targets (external index (EI)), all three techniques were comparable; CI90% ranged from 1.0 to 2.3 and EI from 0 to 5%. Concerning target homogeneity, IMP showed a variance (D5%–D95%) measured on the inner target volume (highest dose prescription) ranging from 5.9 to 13.3%, RA from 5.3 to 11.8%, and HT from 4.0 to 12.2%. The range of minimum significant dose to the same target was: (72.2%, 89.9%) for IMP, (86.7%, 94.1%) for RA, and (79.4%, 94.8%) for HT. Similarly, for maximum significant doses: (103.8%, 109.4%) for IMP, (103.2%, 107.4%) for RA, and (102.4%, 117.2%) for HT. Treatment times (beam-on time) ranged from 123 to 129 s for RA and from 146 to 387 s for HT. Conclusion: Five complex pediatric cases were selected as representative examples to compare three advanced radiation delivery techniques. While differences were noted in the metrics examined, all three techniques provided satisfactory conformal avoidance and conformation.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- DMLC motion tracking of moving targets for intensity modulated arc therapy treatment – a feasibility studyActa Oncologica, 2009
- Indications for tomotherapy/intensity-modulated radiation therapy in paediatric radiotherapy: extracranial diseaseBritish Journal of Radiology, 2008
- Proton Radiotherapy for Childhood Ependymoma: Initial Clinical Outcomes and Dose ComparisonsInternational Journal of Radiation Oncology - Biology - Physics (IJROBP), 2008
- Postoperative Spot-Scanning Proton Radiation Therapy for Chordoma and Chondrosarcoma in Children and Adolescents: Initial Experience at Paul Scherrer InstituteInternational Journal of Radiation Oncology - Biology - Physics (IJROBP), 2008
- On the dosimetric behaviour of photon dose calculation algorithms in the presence of simple geometric heterogeneities: comparison with Monte Carlo calculationsPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2007
- Spot-scanning proton therapy for malignant soft tissue tumors in childhood: First experiences at the Paul Scherrer InstituteInternational Journal of Radiation Oncology - Biology - Physics (IJROBP), 2007
- Tomotherapy and Other Innovative IMRT Delivery SystemsSeminars in Radiation Oncology, 2006
- Out‐of‐field dosimetry measurements for a helical tomotherapy systemJournal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics, 2006
- A 3D photon superposition/convolution algorithm and its foundation on results of Monte Carlo calculations*Physics in Medicine & Biology, 2005
- Intensity-modulated radiation therapy for the treatment of pediatric cancer patientsNature Clinical Practice Oncology, 2005