The Forgotten Torah and the Formation of the Talmudic Subject
Open Access
Abstract
The account of the fetus learning the Torah in its mother’s womb, forgetting it and reacquiring it (b. Niddah 30b) has often been compared to Plato’s doctrine of recollection or anamnesis. This essay argues that such a comparison is misguided, as the Talmudic story does not include the recollection of the forgotten Torah, nor does it address the philosophical difficulties that inform Plato’s doctrine, which arise from a commitment to a two-world ontology. Indeed, the story may be seen as an example of the general absence of a transcendent realm in the Talmud. In Plato’s stead, I argue that Lacan’s formation of the subject offers a more fruitful comparison, and that the Torah-learning fetus may be interpreted as an attempt to overcome the Lacanian moments of alienation that result in humanity’s tragic fate.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Contact Without BorrowingJournal of Ancient Judaism, 2018
- The Rabbinic God and Mediaeval JudaismCurrents in Biblical Research, 2017
- “Famous” Fetuses in Rabbinic Narratives2008
- Mekhilta de R. Simeon b. Yohai2005
- Plato on Knowledge and Forms2003
- Kvl as Hypostasis in the Hebrew BibleJournal of Biblical Literature, 2003
- SHNEI KETUVIM AND RABBINIC INTERMEDIATIONJournal for the Study of Judaism, 2002
- Mirror and Oneiric MiragesThe Harvard Review of Philosophy, 1999
- Recollection and Experience1995
- A History of the Jews in Babylonia, Part 5. Later Sasanian Times1970