Brain Death: A Conclusion in Search of a Justification
Author:
- D. Alan ShewmonDSD. Alan Shewmon
Open Access
- 1 November 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Hastings Center Report
- Vol. 48 (S4) , S22-S25
Abstract
At its inception, “brain death” was proposed not as a coherent concept but as a useful one. The 1968 Ad Hoc Committee of the Harvard Medical School to Examine the Definition of Brain Death gave no reason that “irreversible coma” should be death itself, but simply asserted that the time had come for it to be declared so. Subsequent writings by chairman Henry Beecher made clear that, to him at least, death was essentially a social construct, and society could define it however it pleased. The first widely endorsed attempt at a philosophical justification appeared thirteen years later, with a report from the President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research and a seminal paper by James Bernat, Charles Culver, and Bernard Gert, which introduced the insightful tripartite scheme of concept, criterion, and tests for death. Their paper proposed that the correct concept of death is the “permanent cessation of functioning of the organism as a whole,” which tenuously remains the mainstream concept to this day. In this essay, I focus on this mainstream concept, arguing that equating brain death with death involves several levels of incoherence: between concept and criterion, between criterion and tests, between tests and concept, and between all of these and actual brain death praxis.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- A survey of American neurologists about brain death: understanding the conceptual basis and diagnostic tests for brain deathAnnals of Intensive Care, 2012
- The Apnea Test: Rationale, Confounders, and CriticismJournal of Child Neurology, 2010
- Constructing the Death Elephant: A Synthetic Paradigm Shift for the Definition, Criteria, and Tests for DeathThe Journal of Medicine and Philosophy: A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of Medicine, 2010
- Brain Death: Can It Be Resuscitated?Hastings Center Report, 2009
- The Brain and Somatic Integration: Insights Into the Standard Biological Rationale for Equating Brain Death With DeathThe Journal of Medicine and Philosophy: A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of Medicine, 2001
- Defining DeathArchives of Neurology, 1992
- Electroencephalographic Activity After Brain DeathArchives of Neurology, 1987
- The Definition, Criterion, and Statute of DeathSeminars in Neurology, 1984
- On the Definition and Criterion of DeathAnnals of Internal Medicine, 1981
- A Definition of Irreversible ComaJAMA, 1968